Unfair Pay Practices: Bad for Employees, Worse for Business

Written by Salary.com Staff
October 10, 2023
Unfair Pay Practices: Bad for Employees, Worse for Business

Unfair pay practices have adverse effects on employees. What does not get as much attention is how unfair pay practices are affecting businesses too. When employees discover companies underpay them compared to their coworkers, it damages relationships, breeds hatred, and ruins motivation and loyalty.

This effects cost companies money through lost productivity, high turnover, and damaged culture. Studies show that unfair pay practices reduce productivity by over 25% in affected teams. It can cost over 150% of the salary discrepancy to repair.

Fair and equal pay practices must be a major focus for businesses to flourish.

Are you Paying Fairly and Equally?

How Unfair Pay Practices Hurt Employees and the Business

When companies underpay employees, it hurts morale and productivity. Unfair pay practices lead to higher turnover as people constantly look for better-paying jobs. This results in added costs for hiring and training new staff.

Underpaid employees are less engaged and motivated. They may take more impulsive time off or do the bare minimum. This negatively impacts work quality and customer service.

Unfair pay practices damage the company's reputation and brand. People do not want to support businesses that mistreat employees. This can have major financial effects through loss of sales, clients, partnerships, and prospects.

In contrast, fair pay fosters loyalty, innovation, and excellence. Both the corporation and the employees benefit from this. Paying employees properly is an investment that pays off.

To understand better, here are some of the effects of unfair pay practices.

Damages to Employee Morale and Productivity

Damaged morale and decreased productivity are hidden costs of unfair pay. Employees who believe companies underpay them often feel undervalued and resentful. This saps motivation and focus, causing:

  • Less effort and care in the work.
  • Increased absences and tardiness.
  • Higher turnover as people looks for better opportunities.

Replacing good employees is expensive. The costs to recruit, hire, and train new staff are 1.5-2 times an employee's salary.

Unfair pay practices foster a poor company culture. Employees do not trust the company or see a future there. This erodes team spirit, cooperation, and innovation - all of which are vital to success.

The short-term savings from unfair pay practices end up costing more. The smart business decision is to pay employees fairly. Fair pay helps ensure a loyal, productive workforce and a thriving company. It is an investment that pays off.

Increased Turnover Rates Due to Unfair Pay Practices

Unfair pay practices lead to higher turnover rates within companies. When employees feel companies do not compensate them fairly, they leave for other prospects.

Employees who perceive their pay as unfair often start looking for new jobs where they can receive fair pay. This results in higher turnover rates. This is costly for businesses due to the associated recruitment and training costs of replacing employees.

Keeping experienced employees must be a priority to avoid these costs. Paying employees equitably and competitively within their local job market is the key.

Harm Brand Reputation

Unfair pay practices negatively impact a company’s reputation and brand.

Customers

When unfair pay comes to light, customers often boycott the company. Many take their business to competitors that treat employees fairly. Many will view the company as unethical, and people do not want to support them. Lost customers and revenue seriously damage the bottom line.

Employees

Employees who experience unfair pay practices develop negative feelings towards the company. Morale and productivity suffer as a result. Valued employees may leave for better prospects. They will seek companies who will appreciate and compensate them fairly.

Replacing employees is costly and time-consuming. The company gains a reputation as an undesirable place to work, making it hard to attract top talent.

Investors

Investors want stable, growing companies with strong brands and reputations. Unfair pay practices signal instability and brand damage. The company’s credibility and share price takes a hit as investors lose confidence and trust in the leadership. This mistrust persists even after companies remedy the unfair policies.

Unfair pay practices severely hurt a company. Losing customers, unhappy employees, and wary investors are some of its negative effects. The damage to brand and reputation is long-lasting without sincere effort to make things right.

Missing out on Top Talent

When companies fail to offer fair and equitable pay, they risk missing out on top talent. Prospective employees, especially in competitive fields, will take their skills to employers known for fair pay practices. Unfair pay practices signify a company culture where they value some employees over others.

The Legal Risks of Unfair Pay Practices

Unfair pay practices open companies up to legal risks, including lawsuits over bias and unfair labor practices.

Lawsuits

Companies that pay unfairly face legal action from employees or government agencies such as the EEOC. Employees who feel they suffered inequality may bring claims against the business. There are regulations that prevent unfair pay for workers based on their age, color, or gender.

Companies found guilty of violating these laws must pay large settlements and legal fees. This damages their bottom line and reputation. The risks of litigation give employers ample reason to analyze their pay practices and address unfairness.

Promoting pay equity is in the best interest of both companies and their employees.

Building a Fair Pay Culture for a Stronger Business

Unfair pay practices negatively impact employee morale, productivity, and retention. It damages their relationship with the company and motivation to excel in their roles.

Employees feel they are fairly compensated and given the same treatment in a fair workplace. In a fair-minded company, employees are less likely to experience politics, bias, and favoritism.

Reduced productivity

Employees who receive fair pay are more motivated to put in extra effort. Their work quality and output go beyond what the company expects. Promoting fair pay fosters good relationships between co-workers, improves team dynamics and collaboration.

Higher turnover

Valued employees leave for other prospects that pay them fairly. The costs to rehire and retrain replacements are substantial. By building a fair pay culture, companies reduce regrettable turnover and retain top talent.

Unfair pay practices do more harm than good. These practices result in adverse effects on employee satisfaction, productivity, and retention. Fair compensation for employees is not the only ethical thing to do. It makes strong commercial sense, as smart companies are aware of.

Valuing and investing in human capital through fair pay and benefits proves to boost innovation, loyalty, and long-term success. While change can be difficult, shifting to equitable pay models will future-proof businesses and allow them to attract and retain top talent. Fair pay for all is a win-win.

Insights You Need to Get It Right

The latest research, expert advice, and compensation best practices all in one place.
Creating a Compensation Plan
Creating a Compensation Plan Blog
How the compensation and total rewards planning process create a compensation plan.

Read More

Top Compensation Trends in 2023
Top Compensation Trends in 2023 Blog
Stay ahead of the curve with these top compensation trends for 2023.

Read More

DE&I Panel Discussion: Moving the Conversation Forward
DE&I Panel Discussion: Moving the Conversation Forward Webinar
In this panel discussion we will cover what the issue is when improving DE&I.

Read More

Differences Between HR-Reported and Crowd-Sourced Compensation Data
Differences Between HR-Reported and Crowd-Sourced Compensation Data White paper
To make decisions about the value of a job, you need data from a range of sources.

Read More

CompAnalyst Market Data: Smart Matches, Fast Prices, and New Insights
CompAnalyst Market Data: Smart Matches, Fast Prices, and New Insights Product Sheet
The CompAnalyst Market Data platform is easier to use than ever before.

Read More

It's Easy to Get Started

Transform compensation at your organization and get pay right — see how with a personalized demo.