Does your pay measure up? A guide to compensation benchmarking

With the job market as hot as ever, employees want to make sure they receive fair pay based on their role, experience, and skills. This guide explores the ins and outs of compensation benchmarking, providing employees and employers with the latest stats, best practices, and expert tips for assessing pay.

Learn techniques for gathering competitive intel, assessing a total rewards package, negotiating an employee’s worth, and getting the salary you deserve. Whether you are seeking a raise or a new job, these compensation benchmarking fundamentals are your key to success.

What Is Compensation Benchmarking and Why It Matters

Compensation benchmarking helps companies set fair pay for positions by comparing pay with industry standards. To benchmark, companies analyze pay data from surveys to see how their compensation stacks up for each role.

Why is this important? Paying below the market rate risks losing top talent to competitors. On the other hand, paying too much reduces profits. Benchmarking finds the sweet spot, helping companies attract and keep the best employees at a sustainable cost.

How Does It Work?

Compensation benchmarking uses surveys from reliable sources, private consulting firms, and nonprofit research agencies. These provide aggregated pay data for specific jobs based on factors like experience, education, location, and company size.

Companies then compare their current pay scales to the benchmark to see where they stand. If salaries for certain roles are below average, they can adjust pay to match the norm. If they are paying above market rates, they may freeze increases until the benchmark catches up. Regular benchmarking, often done annually, helps companies make incremental changes to stay competitive.

What Are the Benefits?

When done well, compensation benchmarking leads to:

• Fair, equitable pay: Employees in similar roles earn equal salaries, easing resentment and turnover.
• Cost control: Paying at or slightly above the market rate lets companies offer competitive salaries without reckless spending.
• Improved hiring: Competitive pay attracts more and higher-quality job candidates.
• Increased retention: Employees are less likely to leave for higher pay elsewhere when they are earning a fair wage.

Compensation benchmarking is a key part of a data-driven approach to pay. For companies, it helps ensure pay is fair and sustainable. For employees, it results in equitable, competitive compensation. Benchmarking, in short, leads to a win-win.

How to Conduct Compensation Benchmarking

Compensation benchmarking helps employers know if their pay and benefits are competitive. To conduct effective compensation benchmarking, companies must follow a few best practices.

• Analyze Market Data

The first step is analyzing market pay data from surveys and public data sources. Look at base pay, bonuses, and benefits for specific jobs in an industry and region. See how compensation stacks up against the median and 75th percentile. If an employee is below market, companies may need to adjust pay.

• Review Internal Equity

Next, examine internal pay equity. Are employees with the same experience, education, and duties receiving fair pay relative to each other? If not, adjustments are necessary to avoid anger and turnover. Internal equity is just as critical as external market competitiveness.

• Assess Total Compensation

When benchmarking, consider total compensation, not just base pay. Factor in bonuses, healthcare, retirement plans, paid time off, and other benefits. A total package may be competitive even if base pay is slightly below market. Convey the full value of benefits to employees so they feel adequately compensated.

• Adjust Wisely

If you find pay inequities, correct them in a fair and sustainable way. Consider providing raises over time through a multi-year plan. Compensation changes also often impact the budget, so get leadership buy-in first. With careful planning and consistent benchmarking, companies can achieve both market competitiveness and internal pay equity.

Keeping up with trends in compensation and benefits is challenging but critical. Compensation benchmarking, done well and regularly, helps ensure companies can attract and keep the talent they need to succeed. Staying on top of best practices will serve the business and its employees well.

Do you price jobs accurately?

CompAnalyst® helps you price jobs with confidence.

Free 14-day trial

Compensation Benchmarking: Best Practices and Pitfalls to Avoid

To benchmark compensation effectively, companies need to follow certain best practices.

• Do thorough research on industry standards.

Study reports from reputable sources on salary ranges, benefits, and incentive programs for specific positions. Compare against companies of matching size, location, and business model.

• Analyze your data.

Assess what you currently offer for distinct roles. Look at salaries, bonuses, healthcare, time off, training, and other rewards. See how you stack up against industry norms. You may find you are above the market in some areas but below in others.

• Consider job duties.

Benchmark against positions with similar job duties and experience levels. Entry-level and executive roles, for instance, can vary more between companies. Focus on specific job functions rather than broad job titles.

• Benchmark total compensation.

Do not just look at base pay. Factor in annual bonuses, commissions, stock options, retirement plans, and other benefits that make up an employee's total package. Some companies may offer lower salaries but more generous benefits or bonuses.

• Re-assess regularly.

Conduct benchmarking studies every 1-2 years to stay on top of trends. Make incremental changes to get closer to market standards over time. Major changes all at once can be hard for budgets and employee morale.

Some pitfalls to avoid include relying on outdated or unreliable data. It limits benchmarking to only base salaries rather than total compensation, failing to consider job scope and company variables. Benchmarking must be an ongoing process, not a one-and-done event. With the right approach, it can be a valuable tool for attracting and keeping top talent.

Make Fair Pay a Reality

Match, scope, and price jobs quickly with CompAnalyst®

Request a demo

Conclusion

At the end of the day, benchmarking compensation against industry standards is key to attracting and keeping top talent. While the process can seem daunting, taking the time to research competitive salaries, create thoughtful job descriptions, and use fair pay structures allows companies to compensate employees properly.

With the right strategies and consistent effort, companies of any size can create compensation plans that reflect their values, support their people, and align with their goals. Though the landscape may shift, the basic principles remain the same—compensating people fairly signals trust and care, empowering them to do their best work.