BLOG

9 Performance Management Best Practices That Actually Work

Written by Salary.com Staff

November 13, 2026

9 Performance Management Best Practices That Actually Work
These best practices can help managers set clear goals, give honest feedback, and reward good work all year long.

Key takeaways

  • Set two or three clear, measurable goals for each role.
  • Check in every few weeks to address problems early.
  • Train managers to give clear feedback and explain ratings.
  • Use AI for routine tasks but leave final decisions to managers and HR.

Most employees have sat through a review that felt like a formality. They got a rating, a few vague comments, and no idea what to do next. That's a missed chance to help them grow.

Hire Faster with Real-Time Compensation Context
Combine candidate fits with real-time market pay data to deliver competitive, defensible offers with no costly surprises.
Hire With Confidence

An effective performance management system sets clear expectations, helps managers give useful feedback, and shows employees how their work supports organizational goals. Best of all, it links performance to career development and pay, so good work leads somewhere.

Here are nine performance management best practices to make your review process more useful and improve employee performance.

Connect Performance Reviews Directly to Pay & Rewards
Turn performance evaluations into fair, market-aligned pay decisions while cutting manual spreadsheet reconciliation.
See SalaryTalent

1. Set clear goals tied to real jobs

Goals work best when they match the job. For example, "Improve customer satisfaction" could mean handling support requests faster for a support rep. For a team lead, it could mean helping the team resolve more issues.

So start with two or three clear goals for each role. Define what needs to be done, when it's due, and how success will be measured using key performance indicators (KPIs). This gives employees a clear direction and keeps their work tied to company goals.

Still, setting goals is only half the job. Employees also need to understand them, and many don't. Only 45% clearly understand their performance expectations. To close that gap, managers should review each goal with employees and answer any questions before work begins.

The right performance management software can help here. For instance, SalaryTalent™ Performance connects goals and reviews with job roles, skills, and market pay. That helps managers track progress and spot where employees need improvement.

2. Replace annual reviews with regular check-ins

Clear goals are important, but they only work if managers check in on them. Waiting for the yearly review means problems can go unnoticed for too long. Continuous performance management plans fix this by keeping the conversation going all year.

The simplest way to start is a short one-on-one with each of your direct reports every two weeks or once a month. Fifteen to thirty minutes is enough to cover three questions:

  • What went well?
  • What challenges are you facing?
  • What support do you need?

These performance conversations help managers catch problems early. They also give employees a chance to ask for help. And they make formal reviews easier, because feedback comes up all year instead of in one meeting.

To make the most of them, managers should jot down a few key points after each conversation. These notes make it easier to review progress and give specific examples when the formal review comes around.

3. Train managers to give better and continuous feedback

Check-ins only help if managers know what to say. Most were never taught how to give feedback. They were simply promoted.

The data shows the gap. SHRM found that 41% of talent management executives said getting managers to give objective, constructive feedback was a challenge. Employees notice, too. Only 31% feel their managers are trained in performance management.

The fix doesn't have to be big. A little training goes a long way. Good manager training turns direct managers into coaches, which is crucial for employee engagement and employee retention.

A simple three-part pattern is a good place to start. Teach managers to:

  • Describe the specific behavior they saw
  • Explain the impact it had
  • Agree on what happens next

To build the habit, use role-play. Share examples of good and weak feedback side by side, too. And keep practice short and regular, because it works better than a one-time workshop.

4. Mix ratings with written feedback

Once managers can give good feedback, the next question is how to put it in writing. Should performance appraisals use ratings, comments, or both?

A Harvard Business Review study tested how review formats affect fairness and motivation. In simulated reviews, written feedback was seen as the fairest, especially by employees with room to improve. Ratings still have a place, because they give clear benchmarks to track.

That's why the strongest approach pairs the two. A good review does three things:

  • Gives a rating so employees know where they stand
  • Adds a short note with real examples
  • Names one strength and one area to grow

A number tells workers the score. A story tells them what to do next. So skip vague phrases like "good job" and describe what the employee actually did.

The effort pays off. Giving regular feedback makes employees three times more likely to stay engaged. Companies with regular feedback also see 21% higher profitability.

5. Use AI to cut the admin work

Good feedback takes time, but managers often spend too much of it on tasks that could be handled faster. Gathering data, comparing jobs with market benchmarks, and checking for pay gaps leave less time for coaching employees.

This is where AI can help. It takes the routine work off their plate. For example, Salary.com's AI Agents help HR teams match jobs, set competitive pay, and build salary structures.

People still make the final decisions, though. Managers and HR teams review and approve the results at human checkpoints before anything moves forward. And with less time spent on routine tasks, they can focus on helping employees improve and grow.

6. Recognize good work quickly

Coaching isn't only about fixing problems. Praise matters just as much, and it loses its power when it comes months late. A quick, specific thank you does more than a plaque at the end of the year.

So encourage managers to make recognition a habit. When someone handles a tough client well or helps a teammate, say so that week. Be specific about what they did and why it mattered.

It doesn't have to cost much, either:

  • A quick note or message from the manager
  • A shout-out in a team meeting to celebrate the team's success
  • A small bonus or extra time off for big wins

Employee recognition does one more thing. It shows the team what good work looks like. That quietly sets the standard better than any policy document.

7. Connect employee performance to growth and pay

Praise matters, but employees also want to know how good work leads to better pay and career growth. Without a clear path forward, performance reviews can feel like a formality.

The numbers show why this matters. A Pew Research Center survey found that only 30% of U.S. workers were very or extremely satisfied with their pay, and just 26% felt the same about promotion opportunities.

Employers have a stake in this, too. Companies that focus on employee performance are 4.2 times more likely to outperform their peers.

Performance reviews can help close that gap. When they show employees how to grow, people have something to work toward. Managers should:

  • Show employees which roles they can move into.
  • Identify the skills they need to advance, including soft skills, and include them in an employee development plan.
  • Explain how performance affects raises and promotions.

Pay plays a part here, too. Make sure top performers earn competitive salaries, or they may take their skills elsewhere.

Make Every Talent Decision Compensation-First
Unite workforce data, performance metrics, and market pay intelligence on one AI-native platform to see labor costs before you commit.
Book a Demo

8. Manage remote and hybrid teams by outcomes

Rewarding performance fairly gets harder when employees work in different places. Managers can easily give more credit to team members they see in the office, but being visible doesn't mean doing better work.

The fix is to measure results, not presence. Set clear expectations before work begins, such as completing a report, building a working prototype, or improving response times. Then assess employees against those measurable outcomes.

Three habits help keep reviews fair:

  • Record goals and decisions in shared team tools.
  • Keep open communication going through regular check-ins.
  • Focus on results, not online hours or response speed.

Together, these habits give everyone a fair chance to be judged on their work, wherever they work.

9. Review your process every year

Even a good performance management process needs regular updates. Roles change, teams grow, and old methods may no longer work.

Review the process once a year and ask:

  • Do employees find reviews fair and useful?
  • Do managers have the time and skills to give good feedback?
  • Do reviews lead to decisions about pay and promotions?

Use a short survey and talk to a few managers to find out what needs to change. Make one or two improvements, then tell employees what you changed and why.

Small, regular improvements are easier to manage than a major overhaul every few years. That's continuous improvement in practice.

Make performance management practices part of the bigger picture

Strong performance management is not a single tool or a single meeting. It is a habit of clear goals, honest feedback, and fair rewards. When those pieces connect, people know where they stand and where they can go.

For a performance management system that brings it all together, take a look at SalaryTalent™. It is a compensation-first talent management platform that brings workforce, pay, and real-time market data into recruiting, performance, and workforce decisions. That way, every review, raise, and promotion is made with the full picture.

Decorative background image

Insights you need to get it right

The latest research, expert advice, and compensation best practices all in one place.

Get Pay Right on ADP Workforce Now® Next Gen™

Blog

Get Pay Right on ADP Workforce Now® Next Gen™

Bringing trusted compensation intelligence and seamless planning to even more ADP users.

Read more
A Definitive Guide to Educating Managers on Pay Discussions

Blog

A Definitive Guide to Educating Managers on Pay Discussions

Learn how to train managers for effective pay conversations and build trust.

Read more
The Ultimate Guide to Designing Flexible Total Rewards Packages

Blog

The Ultimate Guide to Designing Flexible Total Rewards Packages

Total rewards package flexibility lets employees choose what matters - pay, perks, and benefits tailored to their needs.

Read more

It’s easy to get started

Transform compensation at your organization and get pay right — see how with a personalized demo.