What are the main factors that influence an Insurance Claims Service Supervisor's salary?

The primary factors are: 1) Experience Level, 2) Geographic Location, 3) Education/Skills, 4) Company Size & Industry

What industry pays the highest salary for Insurance Claims Service Supervisor?

The Healthcare industry offers the highest average compensation for Insurance Claims Service Supervisor roles, with salaries approximately 50% above the market median.

How does experience change An Insurance Claims Service Supervisor's salary?

An Insurance Claims Service Supervisor's salary grows with experience: an Insurance Claims Service Supervisor (0-3 years)earns $69,151, an Insurance Claim Service Manager I (3-5 years)earns $96,287, an Insurance Claim Service Manager II (5+ years)earns $110,455,

What are the highest paying states for an Insurance Claims Service Supervisor?

Insurance Claims Service Supervisor salary varies significantly by state. The top 3 highest paying states for Insurance Claims Service Supervisor roles are District of Columbia $82,665, California $82,351, Massachusetts $81,254. These tech hubs typically pay 10-15% above the national average.

How much do different types of Insurance Claims Service Supervisor roles make?

Salaries for Insurance Claims Service Supervisor level roles vary by specialization: Insurance Claims Service Manager II: $119,256; Insurance Claims Customer Service Manager I: $103,960; Insurance Claims Service Manager I: $103,959; Health Insurance Service Operations Supervisor: $89,416; Insurance Claims Customer Service Supervisor: $74,670.

Insurance Claims Service Supervisor Salary in New Mexico

How much does an Insurance Claims Service Supervisor make in New Mexico?

As of August 01, 2026, the average salary for an Insurance Claims Service Supervisor in New Mexico is $69,151 per year, which breaks down to an hourly rate of $33.

However, an Insurance Claims Service Supervisor's salary can vary significantly. Here’s a look at the typical salary range:

Top Earners (90th percentile): $81,675
Majority Range (25th-75th percentile): $66,155 to $75,707
Entry-Level (10th percentile): $63,427

10% $63,427

50% (Median) $69,151

90% $81,675

Insurance Claims Service Supervisor Salaries by Percentile

	Annual Salary	Monthly Pay	Weekly Pay	Hourly Wage
75th Percentile	$75,707	$6,309	$1,456	$36
Average	$69,151	$5,763	$1,330	$33
25th Percentile	$66,155	$5,513	$1,272	$32

Salary Factors Salary by Experience Related Job Salaries Top Paying Cities Explore Related Jobs

For HR & Compensation Team

What should I pay?

See how Salary.com helps teams price roles more accurately.

Benchmark Insurance Claims Service Supervisor with confidence

Get deeper market data to support decisions.

Work Email

Phone No.

Choose a perfect time to talk with a compensation expert.

Book a Demo

Key Factors That Influence Insurance Claims Service Supervisor Salaries

An Insurance Claims Service Supervisor's salary isn't a fixed number. It's shaped by several important factors. Below, we'll explore how your years of experience, geographic location and company size can directly affect your earning potential.

How Experience Level Affects Insurance Claims Service Supervisor Salaries?

Experience is a primary driver of an Insurance Claims Service Supervisor's salary. As you build your skills and take on more complex tasks, your compensation generally increases. Here's how the average salary grows at different career stages:

Insurance Claims Service Supervisor (0-3 years): $69,151
Insurance Claim Service Manager I (3-5 years): $96,287
Insurance Claim Service Manager II (5+ years): $110,455

Job Role	Years of Experience	Average Salary
Insurance Claims Service Supervisor	0-3 years	$69,151
Insurance Claim Service Manager I	3-5 years	$96,287
Insurance Claim Service Manager II	5+ years	$110,455

View as Graph

How Do Insurance Claims Service Supervisors Salaries Vary from State to State?

Your salary can change significantly depending on where you work. States with a higher cost of living and strong industrial sectors often pay more to attract Insurance Claims Service Supervisors. For example, consider the average annual salaries in these key locations:

District of Columbia: $82,665.
California: $82,351.
Massachusetts: $81,254.

District of Columbia $82,665 California $82,351 Massachusetts $81,254 Washington $80,955 New Jersey $80,925 Alaska $80,821 Connecticut $79,790 New York $79,372

Hawaii $78,036 Rhode Island $77,409 Maryland $76,983 Minnesota $76,401 Colorado $76,177 Illinois $76,102 Oregon $75,818 Delaware $75,609

New Hampshire $75,478 Virginia $75,184 Pennsylvania $74,325 Nevada $73,892 North Dakota $73,750 Michigan $73,526 Wisconsin $73,444 Vermont $73,280

Texas $72,824 Maine $72,794 Arizona $72,750 Ohio $72,697 Georgia $72,011 Indiana $71,667 Wyoming $71,600 Utah $71,495

Iowa $71,451 Kansas $71,092 Louisiana $70,988 North Carolina $70,950 Missouri $70,935 Florida $70,644 Montana $70,487 Nebraska $70,338

Kentucky $70,256 South Carolina $69,957 Tennessee $69,771 Idaho $69,696 New Mexico $69,151 Oklahoma $69,032 Alabama $68,591 South Dakota $67,852

Arkansas $67,449 West Virginia $67,232 Mississippi $66,583

Top Paying Cities for Insurance Claims Service Supervisor

Salaries can also vary between different cities. Major metropolitan areas or cities with a high demand for technicians often offer more competitive pay. Here are a few examples of average annual salaries in different U.S. cities:

Algodones: $69,887
Belen: $69,498
Bernalillo: $70,011

Algodones, NM $69,887 Belen, NM $69,498 Bernalillo, NM $70,011 Bluewater, NM $68,541 Bosque, NM $68,988 Casa Blanca, NM $69,144 Cedar Crest, NM $70,069 Cedarvale, NM $67,322

Cerrillos, NM $69,938 Claunch, NM $67,072 Coyote, NM $68,908 Cuba, NM $68,797 Cubero, NM $69,297 Edgewood, NM $69,757 Estancia, NM $68,925 Gallina, NM $68,547

Counselor, NM $68,590 Grants, NM $68,463 Milan, NM $68,737 Isleta, NM $70,131 Jarales, NM $69,431 Jemez Pueblo, NM $69,551 Jemez Springs, NM $69,337 Laguna, NM $69,636

La Jara, NM $68,720 La Joya, NM $68,561 Lindrith, NM $68,478 Los Lunas, NM $69,866 Mcintosh, NM $69,304 Pueblo Of Acoma, NM $68,843 Moriarty, NM $69,071 Mountainair, NM $68,326

Nageezi, NM $68,498 New Laguna, NM $69,263 Paguate, NM $69,310 Pena Blanca, NM $70,084 Peralta, NM $69,977 Placitas, NM $70,013 Ponderosa, NM $69,463 Prewitt, NM $68,520

Regina, NM $68,568 Sandia Park, NM $69,893 Corrales, NM $70,157 San Fidel, NM $68,890 San Rafael, NM $68,596 Santo Domingo Pueblo, NM $69,894 San Ysidro, NM $69,800 Stanley, NM $69,061

Tijeras, NM $69,902 Tome, NM $69,773 Torreon, NM $69,541 Veguita, NM $68,982 Willard, NM $68,203 Youngsville, NM $68,927 Bosque Farms, NM $70,105 Clines Corners, NM $68,644

Cochiti Pueblo, NM $69,947 Cochiti Lake, NM $70,038 Albuquerque, NM $70,196 Kirtland Afb, NM $70,196 Rio Rancho, NM $70,081 Gallup, NM $68,619 Brimhall, NM $68,425 Church Rock, NM $68,457

Continental Divide, NM $68,409 Crownpoint, NM $68,466 Fence Lake, NM $68,160 Fort Wingate, NM $68,434 Gamerco, NM $68,549 Mentmore, NM $68,442 Mexican Springs, NM $68,434 Ramah, NM $68,309

Rehoboth, NM $68,480 Thoreau, NM $68,484 Tohatchi, NM $68,421 Vanderwagen, NM $68,434 Zuni, NM $68,418 Navajo, NM $68,511 Jamestown, NM $68,341 Pinehill, NM $68,256

Sheep Springs, NM $68,495 Smith Lake, NM $68,750 Yatahey, NM $68,470 Farmington, NM $68,799 Aztec, NM $68,926 Blanco, NM $68,604 Bloomfield, NM $68,523 Flora Vista, NM $68,870

Fruitland, NM $68,439 Kirtland, NM $68,871 La Plata, NM $68,896 Navajo Dam, NM $68,865 Shiprock, NM $68,770 Waterflow, NM $68,734 Newcomb, NM $68,453 Sanostee, NM $68,496

Santa Fe, NM $70,555 Abiquiu, NM $68,625 Alcalde, NM $69,820 Amalia, NM $68,520 Arroyo Hondo, NM $68,424 Arroyo Seco, NM $68,503 Canjilon, NM $68,413 Canones, NM $69,036

Carson, NM $68,686 Cebolla, NM $68,453 Cerro, NM $68,473 Chama, NM $68,753 Chamisal, NM $69,635 Chimayo, NM $70,124 Cordova, NM $70,005 Costilla, NM $68,808

Taos Ski Valley, NM $68,286 Dixon, NM $69,568 Dulce, NM $68,752 El Prado, NM $68,563 El Rito, NM $68,878 Embudo, NM $69,211 Espanola, NM $70,039 Glorieta, NM $70,283

Hernandez, NM $69,388 Ilfeld, NM $69,634 La Madera, NM $68,757 Lamy, NM $70,015 Llano, NM $69,494 Los Alamos, NM $70,181 White Rock, NM $70,313 Medanales, NM $69,465

Ojo Caliente, NM $69,056 Los Ojos, NM $68,584 Pecos, NM $70,064 Penasco, NM $69,235 Petaca, NM $68,349 Questa, NM $68,546 Ranchos De Taos, NM $68,907 Red River, NM $68,350

Ribera, NM $68,790 Rowe, NM $69,700 San Cristobal, NM $68,348 San Jose, NM $69,528 Ohkay Owingeh, NM $69,868 Santa Cruz, NM $70,100 Serafina, NM $68,616 Taos, NM $68,524

Tererro, NM $70,288 Tesuque, NM $70,555 Tierra Amarilla, NM $68,524 Trampas, NM $69,179 Tres Piedras, NM $68,330 Truchas, NM $69,810 Vadito, NM $69,144 Valdez, NM $68,399

Vallecitos, NM $68,345 Velarde, NM $69,463 Villanueva, NM $68,657 Spaceport City, NM $67,257 Las Vegas, NM $68,074 Angel Fire, NM $68,275 Anton Chico, NM $67,956 Buena Vista, NM $68,581

Chacon, NM $68,629 Cimarron, NM $68,168 Cleveland, NM $69,116 Eagle Nest, NM $68,220 Guadalupita, NM $68,524 Holman, NM $68,940 La Loma, NM $67,842 Maxwell, NM $68,192

Miami, NM $68,045 Mills, NM $67,803 Montezuma, NM $69,467 Mora, NM $69,213 Mosquero, NM $67,744 Ocate, NM $68,118 Ojo Feliz, NM $68,298 Rainsville, NM $68,597

Raton, NM $68,363 Rociada, NM $69,502 Roy, NM $67,818 Sapello, NM $68,899 Solano, NM $67,735 Springer, NM $68,015 Ute Park, NM $68,201 Valmora, NM $68,017

Wagon Mound, NM $67,939 Watrous, NM $68,040 Socorro, NM $67,883 Aragon, NM $68,088 Datil, NM $67,807 Lemitar, NM $68,198 Luna, NM $68,209 Magdalena, NM $67,812

Pie Town, NM $68,039 Polvadera, NM $68,363 Quemado, NM $68,180 Reserve, NM $68,057 San Acacia, NM $68,475 San Antonio, NM $67,507 Truth Or Consequences, NM $67,493 Arrey, NM $67,482

Caballo, NM $67,528 Derry, NM $67,184 Elephant Butte, NM $67,668 Garfield, NM $66,990 Hatch, NM $65,916 Monticello, NM $67,489 Rincon, NM $65,537 Salem, NM $66,781

Williamsburg, NM $67,578 Winston, NM $67,538 Las Cruces, NM $64,679 White Sands Missile Range, NM $64,891 Santa Teresa, NM $65,363 Playas, NM $67,805 Animas, NM $67,971 Anthony, NM $65,347

Arenas Valley, NM $67,851 Bayard, NM $67,788 Berino, NM $65,051 Buckhorn, NM $67,859 Santa Clara, NM $67,907 Chamberino, NM $65,119 Cliff, NM $67,780 Columbus, NM $67,598

Deming, NM $67,614 Dona Ana, NM $64,681 Fairacres, NM $64,874 Faywood, NM $67,582 Fort Bayard, NM $67,842 Gila, NM $67,680 Glenwood, NM $67,733 Hachita, NM $67,598

Hanover, NM $67,612 Hillsboro, NM $67,474 Hurley, NM $67,743 La Mesa, NM $65,916 Lordsburg, NM $67,755 Mesilla, NM $64,680 Mesilla Park, NM $64,687 Mesquite, NM $64,742

Mimbres, NM $67,666 Mule Creek, NM $67,849 Organ, NM $64,721 Pinos Altos, NM $67,779 Radium Springs, NM $64,706 Redrock, NM $67,606 Rodeo, NM $68,057 San Miguel, NM $64,718

Silver City, NM $67,779 Sunland Park, NM $65,015 Tyrone, NM $67,980 Vado, NM $64,768 Chaparral, NM $65,585 Clovis, NM $67,650 Cannon Afb, NM $67,500 Broadview, NM $67,452

Causey, NM $67,337 Crossroads, NM $67,177 Dora, NM $67,497 Elida, NM $67,217 Floyd, NM $67,380 Fort Sumner, NM $67,326 Grady, NM $67,517 House, NM $67,463

Kenna, NM $67,217 Lingo, NM $67,332 Melrose, NM $67,474 Milnesand, NM $67,190 Pep, NM $67,282 Portales, NM $67,529 Rogers, NM $67,301 Saint Vrain, NM $67,517

Taiban, NM $67,302 Texico, NM $67,544 Yeso, NM $67,058 Roswell, NM $67,136 Artesia, NM $67,269 Caprock, NM $67,132 Carlsbad, NM $67,313 Dexter, NM $67,184

Eunice, NM $67,373 Hagerman, NM $67,217 Hobbs, NM $67,471 Hope, NM $66,971 Jal, NM $67,293 Lake Arthur, NM $67,106 Lakewood, NM $67,206 Loco Hills, NM $67,330

Loving, NM $67,296 Lovington, NM $67,406 Mcdonald, NM $67,223 Malaga, NM $67,230 Maljamar, NM $67,164 Monument, NM $67,323 Tatum, NM $67,266 Whites City, NM $67,379

Carrizozo, NM $66,818 Alamogordo, NM $66,605 Alto, NM $66,828 Bent, NM $66,618 Capitan, NM $66,672 Cloudcroft, NM $66,610 Corona, NM $67,108 Encino, NM $67,647

Fort Stanton, NM $66,701 Glencoe, NM $66,653 High Rolls Mountain Park, NM $66,598 Holloman Air Force Base, NM $66,598 Hondo, NM $66,714 La Luz, NM $66,598 Lincoln, NM $66,520 Mayhill, NM $66,748

Mescalero, NM $66,627 Nogal, NM $66,913 Orogrande, NM $66,631 Picacho, NM $66,700 Pinon, NM $66,951 Ruidoso, NM $66,954 Ruidoso Downs, NM $66,863 Sacramento, NM $66,657

San Patricio, NM $66,736 Sunspot, NM $66,598 Timberon, NM $66,742 Tinnie, NM $66,661 Tularosa, NM $66,642 Vaughn, NM $67,375 Weed, NM $66,740 Tucumcari, NM $67,709

Amistad, NM $67,622 Bard, NM $67,514 Capulin, NM $68,278 Clayton, NM $67,753 Conchas Dam, NM $67,815 Cuervo, NM $67,488 Des Moines, NM $68,009 Folsom, NM $68,114

Garita, NM $67,685 Gladstone, NM $67,821 Grenville, NM $67,808 Logan, NM $67,707 Mcalister, NM $67,497 Nara Visa, NM $67,547 Newkirk, NM $67,621 Quay, NM $67,660

San Jon, NM $67,588 Santa Rosa, NM $67,660 Sedan, NM $67,684 Trementina, NM $67,681

Insurance Claims Service Supervisor Salary by Company Size: Startups vs. Enterprise

Insurance Claims Service Supervisor salary potential scales significantly with company size. Data shows that Enterprise companies (5,000+ employees) pay the highest average salary at around $74,629. While startup companies pay approximate $63,286.

Insurance Claims Service Supervisor Salary by Company Size

Company Size	Employees	Average Salary
Startup	1~50	$63,286
Growth Stage	51~500	$66,899
Established	501~5000	$72,101
Enterprise	5000+	$74,629

Insurance Claims Service Supervisor Salary by Industry: Top Paying Sectors

For Insurance Claims Service Supervisor roles, the industry you choose can affect earning potential by as much as 120% (the gap between the highest and lowest paying industries). Data shows that the Healthcare and Financial Services sectors offer the strongest compensation, at 50% above the average. In contrast, Insurance Claims Service Supervisor positions in Insurance or Business Services typically offer lower base pay, as these industries often view Insurance Claims Service Supervisor as a support function rather than a direct revenue driver.

The top paying industries for an Insurance Claims Service Supervisor

Industry Sector	Average Annual Salary	Average Hourly Rate	Pay vs.Avg
Healthcare	$111,992	$54.0	50%
Financial Services	$97,059	$47.0	30%
Edu., Gov't. & Nonprofit	$82,127	$39.0	10%

Insurance Claims Service Supervisor Salary: Hourly Rate, Weekly Pay, and Monthly Pay

Understanding how an Insurance Claims Service Supervisor's annual salary breaks down can help with budgeting. Below, you can see the average hourly rate, weekly pay, and monthly pay for this role. Use the buttons to switch between different pay periods.

$66,155

Average $69,151/year

$75,707

$5,513

Average $5,763/month

$6,309

$1,272

Average $1,330/week

$1,456

$32

Average $33/hour

$36

	Annual Salary	Monthly Pay	Weekly Pay	Hourly Wage
75th Percentile	$75,707	$6,309	$1,456	$36
Average	$69,151	$5,763	$1,330	$33
25th Percentile	$66,155	$5,513	$1,272	$32

Insurance Claims Service Supervisor Salary Growth & Career Path

Insurance Claims Service Supervisor

Next Role

Advancement

Insurance Claims Service Manager I Insurance Claims Service Manager II

For an Insurance Claims Service Supervisor, the most direct path to higher earnings is advancing to the Insurance Claims Service Manager I role. This promotion typically comes with a significant pay increase, bringing the average annual salary to $96,287 - a projected growth of 39% over your current level.

Find Your Next Insurance Claims Service Supervisor Job

Ready to take the next step in your career? Browse thousands of current Insurance Claims Service Supervisor job openings on our job board. Use the search bar below to find your perfect match.

For Employees

Analyze the market and your qualifications to negotiate your salary with confidence.

Get a Salary Increase

Search thousands of open positions to find your next opportunity.

Search Job Openings

For Employers

Individualize employee pay based on unique job requirements and personal qualifications.

Adjust Employee Salary

Get the latest market price for benchmark jobs and jobs in your industry.

Price My Industry Jobs

Cost of Living In New Mexico

Cost of Living in New Mexico is

-7.4% Lower

than the National Average

Use Salary.com's Cost of Living Calculator to find out what income you need to maintain your standard of living in a different city and how much more or less money you need to budget for basic expenses.

Explore Cost of Living Calculator

Empower Your Team

Salary.com experts will help you thrive your workplaces.

Find Salary.com Comp Consulting

See Salary Trends in 2025

Salary.com provides salary survey data for thousands of industry Jobs.

Price Your Company Jobs and Make Pay Fair

Where Does Our Salary Data Come From?

Salary.com salary estimates, histograms, trends, and comparisons are derived from both employer job postings and third-party data sources. We also provide multiple percentiles of salary information for your reference, click here to know Why the Salary Midpoint Formula Is Crucial to Getting Pay Equity Right. With more online, real-time compensation data than any other website, Salary.com helps you determine your exact pay target.

Are you an HR manager or compensation specialist?

Salary.com's CompAnalyst platform offers:

Detailed skills and competency reports for specific positions
Job and employee pricing reports
Compensation data tools, salary structures, surveys and benchmarks.

Learn about

Salary Search

Salary Calculator Tools

Know Your Worth

Advance at Work

Explore Career Path

Land Your Next Role

Software + AI

Data

Survey Catalogue

Insurance Claims Service Supervisor Salary in New Mexico

How much does an Insurance Claims Service Supervisor make in New Mexico?

Key Factors That Influence Insurance Claims Service Supervisor Salaries

How Experience Level Affects Insurance Claims Service Supervisor Salaries?

How Do Insurance Claims Service Supervisors Salaries Vary from State to State?

Top Paying Cities for Insurance Claims Service Supervisor

Insurance Claims Service Supervisor Salary by Company Size: Startups vs. Enterprise

Insurance Claims Service Supervisor Salary by Company Size

Insurance Claims Service Supervisor Salary by Industry: Top Paying Sectors

The top paying industries for an Insurance Claims Service Supervisor

Insurance Claims Service Supervisor Salary: Hourly Rate, Weekly Pay, and Monthly Pay

Insurance Claims Service Supervisor Salary Growth & Career Path

Find Your Next Insurance Claims Service Supervisor Job

For Employees

For Employers

Cost of Living In New Mexico

Where Does Our Salary Data Come From?

Are you an HR manager or compensation specialist?

Insurance Claims Service Supervisor Salary in New Mexico

How much does an Insurance Claims Service Supervisor make in New Mexico?

Key Factors That Influence Insurance Claims Service Supervisor Salaries

How Experience Level Affects Insurance Claims Service Supervisor Salaries?

How Do Insurance Claims Service Supervisors Salaries Vary from State to State?

Top Paying Cities for Insurance Claims Service Supervisor

Insurance Claims Service Supervisor Salary by Company Size: Startups vs. Enterprise

Insurance Claims Service Supervisor Salary by Company Size

Insurance Claims Service Supervisor Salary by Industry: Top Paying Sectors

The top paying industries for an Insurance Claims Service Supervisor

Insurance Claims Service Supervisor Salary: Hourly Rate, Weekly Pay, and Monthly Pay

Insurance Claims Service Supervisor Salary Growth & Career Path

Salaries of Jobs related to Insurance Claims Service Supervisors

Find Your Next Insurance Claims Service Supervisor Job

For Employees

For Employers

Cost of Living In New Mexico

Where Does Our Salary Data Come From?

Are you an HR manager or compensation specialist?