How much does a Claims Supervisor I make in the United States? The average Claims Supervisor I salary in the United States is $80,358 as of June 27, 2024, but the range typically falls between $69,354 and $93,489. Salary ranges can vary widely depending on many important factors, including education, certifications, additional skills, the number of years you have spent in your profession. With more online, real-time compensation data than any other website, helps you determine your exact pay target. 

Claims Supervisor I Salaries by Percentile
Percentile Salary Location Last Updated
10th Percentile Claims Supervisor I Salary $59,335 US June 27, 2024
25th Percentile Claims Supervisor I Salary $69,354 US June 27, 2024
50th Percentile Claims Supervisor I Salary $80,358 US June 27, 2024
75th Percentile Claims Supervisor I Salary $93,489 US June 27, 2024
90th Percentile Claims Supervisor I Salary $105,444 US June 27, 2024
25% $69,354 10% $59,335 90% $105,444 75% $93,489 $80,358 50%(Median) Didn’t find job title? Click
Change Search Criteria

What skills does a Claims Supervisor I need?

Each competency has five to ten behavioral assertions that can be observed, each with a corresponding performance level (from one to five) that is required for a particular job.


Leadership: Knowledge of and ability to employ effective strategies that motivate and guide other members within our business to achieve optimum results.


Microsoft Office: Microsoft Office is a suite of desktop productivity applications that is designed by Microsoft for business use. You can create documents containing text and images, work with data in spreadsheets and databases, create presentations and posters.


Group Insurance: A type of insurance plan that covers a number of people in the same contract. Such a plan provides the same level of insurance coverage to all members of a group irrespective of their age, gender, occupation or socio-economic status.

Leadership 9.68%
Microsoft Office 1.75%
Group Insurance 1.19%
Others 87.38%
download asset banner
Facing Salary Structure Challenges? Let Our Expert Guide You
The job market is increasingly challenging. Our whitepaper, Navigating the Challenges of Creating Salary Structures, offers guidance on creating salary structures. Provide your phone number and work email to download the full version.
We will handle your contact details in line with our Privacy Policy. If you prefer not to receive marketing emails from, you can opt-out out of marketing communications at any time by clicking unsubscribe.

Job Description for Claims Supervisor I

Claims Supervisor I supervises activities in the claims department. Leads the examination of personal and property and casualty insurance claims based on policy provisions, appraisal, and verifiable damage. Being a Claims Supervisor I interacts with claimants and oversees the review of records and documentation to ascertain insurance coverage. Supervises settlement negotiations within authorized limits and escalates claims exceeding authorization. Additionally, Claims Supervisor I may conduct team training. May require a bachelor's degree. Typically reports to a manager or head of a unit/department. Working team member that may validate or coordinate the work of others on a support team. Suggests improvements to process, is a knowledge resource for other team members. Has no authority for staff actions. Generally has a minimum of 2 years experience as an individual contributor. Thorough knowledge of the team processes. (Copyright 2024 View full job description

Employers: Job Description Management Tool

See user submitted job responsibilities for Claims Supervisor I. job board provides millions of Claims Supervisor I information for you to search for. Click on search button below to see Claims Supervisor I job openings or enter a new job title here.

Job Openings for Claims Supervisor I
  • Jamestown Family Health Clinic is looking for a full-time, benefited, Clinic RN I, who is highly motivated and can assume multiple roles based on clinic ne...
    - 1 Month Ago
  • Take your tractor trailer and estimating skills out of the shop and into the field with a career as a Commercial Auto Claims Field Adjuster. This position ...
    - 1 Month Ago
  • Be part of a team where every day you make a difference. We are looking for a new Claims Processor who will provide exceptional customer service. As a Clai...
    - 21 Days Ago
  • This position offers the option of a hybrid work schedule based out of South Sioux City, NE, Arlington, TX, Boise, ID, Bloomington, IN or Knoxville, TN. Po...
    - 1 Month Ago
  • Center 1 (19052), United States of America, McLean, Virginia. Director. Software Engineering - Fraud disputes and claims. We are seeking a Director of Soft...
    - 5 Days Ago

Career Path for Claims Supervisor I

A career path is a sequence of jobs that leads to your short- and long-term career goals. Some follow a linear career path within one field, while others change fields periodically to achieve career or personal goals.

For Claims Supervisor I, the first career path typically progresses to Claims Supervisor II.

Those that have already made the climb...
John D. Rainey, Former Chief Financial Officer and EVP, Global Customer Operations
PayPal Holdings, Inc. operates a technology platform that enables digital payments on behalf of merchants and consumers worldwide. The company provides payment solutions under the PayPal, PayPal Credit, Braintree, Venmo, Xoom, PayPal Zettle, Hyperwallet, PayPal Honey, and Paidy names. Its payments platform allows consu... More
Fiscal Year Ended in 2022
Not the job you're looking for? Search more salaries here:
See if your skills match up? Check skills for Claims Supervisor I

Are you an HR manager or compensation specialist?'s CompAnalyst platform offers:

  • Detailed skills and competency reports for specific positions
  • Job and employee pricing reports
  • Compensation data tools, salary structures, surveys and benchmarks.
Learn about CompAnalyst

Claims Supervisor I salary varies from city to city. Compared with national average salary of Claims Supervisor I, the highest Claims Supervisor I salary is in San Francisco, CA, where the Claims Supervisor I salary is 25.0% above. The lowest Claims Supervisor I salary is in Miami, FL, where the Claims Supervisor I salary is 3.5% lower than national average salary.

City, State Compared to national average
City, State San Francisco, CA Compared to national average
+ 25.0%
City, State Washington, DC Compared to national average
+ 11.3%
City, State Miami, FL Compared to national average
City, State Chicago, IL Compared to national average
+ 4.9%
City, State Boston, MA Compared to national average
+ 12.1%
City, State New York, NY Compared to national average
+ 16.8%
City, State Dallas, TX Compared to national average

Take just three simple steps below to generate your own personalized salary report

Step 1 of 3

Understand the total compensation opportunity for a Claims Supervisor I, base salary plus other pay elements

Average Base Salary

Core compensation


Average Total Cash Compensation

Includes base and annual incentives

These charts show the average base salary (core compensation), as well as the average total cash compensation for the job of Claims Supervisor I in the United States. The base salary for Claims Supervisor I ranges from $69,354 to $93,489 with the average base salary of $80,358. The total cash compensation, which includes base, and annual incentives, can vary anywhere from $72,478 to $98,759 with the average total cash compensation of $84,802.
Similar Job Titles:
Step 2 of 3

Discover how your pay is adjusted for skills, experience, and other factors

How much should you be paid?

For a real-time salary target, tell us more about your role in the four categories below.



Step 3 of 3

How much should you be paid?

View the Cost of Living in Major Cities

Skills associated with Claims Supervisor I: Inquiry Research/Response, Customer Support, Calculate Payments/Premiums, Claim Reviews ...More

Recently searched related titles: Claims Negotiator, Claims Team Lead, Environmental Officer

Jobs with a similar salary range to Claims Supervisor I : Prior Authorization Supervisor, Claims Unit Supervisor

Salary estimation for Claims Supervisor I at companies like : Ball State FCU, Rig Diggers Freight Management, KARO - REAL - INVEST INTERNATIONAL Inc

Jobs with a similar salary range to Claims Supervisor I : Emergency Medicine Resident, Junior Pm, Ice Rink Manager

Claims Supervisor I Salary in United States
Claims Supervisor I Salary Graph, Regional Distribution and Summary