Salary AI Book a Demo
upper level job

Claims Supervisor I Salary in the United States

How much does a Claims Supervisor I make in the United States?

As of August 01, 2026, the average salary for a Claims Supervisor I in the United States is $76,325 per year, which breaks down to an hourly rate of $37.

However, a Claims Supervisor I's salary can vary significantly. Here’s a look at the typical salary range:

  • Top Earners (90th percentile): $85,690
  • Majority Range (25th-75th percentile): $68,322 to $81,227
  • Entry-Level (10th percentile): $61,036
Salary Factors Salary-Boosting Skills Salary by Experience Related Job Salaries Top Paying Cities Explore Related Jobs

Key Factors That Influence Claims Supervisor I Salaries

A Claims Supervisor I's salary isn't a fixed number. It's shaped by several important factors. Below, we'll explore how your years of experience, geographic location, education and company size can directly affect your earning potential.

How Experience Level Affects Claims Supervisor I Salaries?

Experience is a primary driver of a Claims Supervisor I's salary. As you build your skills and take on more complex tasks, your compensation generally increases. Here's how the average salary grows at different career stages:

  • Claims Examiner IV (7+ years): $95,575
  • Claims Examiner V (7-10 years): $119,807
  • Claims Supervisor I (10+ years): $76,325
  • Claims Supervisor II (10+ years): $100,739
  • Claims Manager (10+ years): $127,630
Job Role Years of Experience Average Salary
Claims Examiner IV7+ years$95,575
Claims Examiner V7-10 years$119,807
Claims Supervisor I10+ years$76,325
Claims Supervisor II10+ years$100,739
Claims Manager10+ years$127,630
View as Graph

How Do Claims Supervisor Is Salaries Vary from State to State?

Your salary can change significantly depending on where you work. States with a higher cost of living and strong industrial sectors often pay more to attract Claims Supervisor Is. For example, consider the average annual salaries in these key locations:
  • District of Columbia: $84,507.
  • California: $84,186.
  • Massachusetts: $83,064.

Top Paying Cities for Claims Supervisor I

Salaries can also vary between different cities. Major metropolitan areas or cities with a high demand for technicians often offer more competitive pay. Here are a few examples of average annual salaries in different U.S. cities:

  • San Jose: $96,269
  • San Francisco: $95,215
  • Oakland: $93,208

What Skills Can Increase a Claims Supervisor I's Salary?

Demanded Skills for the Role:

  • Leadership (Mentioned in 10.8% Job Postings): Knowledge of and ability to employ effective strategies that motivate and guide other members within our business to achieve optimum results.
  • Billing (Mentioned in 2.46% Job Postings): Billing refers to the aspect of banking, whereby someone is charged accurately for what item they purchased.
  • Claims Management (Mentioned in 1.39% Job Postings): Claims Management means the process of identifying, controlling and resolving demands by individuals or public entities to recover losses from any Member of the Association.
Skills Demand Percentage
Leadership 10.8%
Billing 2.46%
Claims Management 1.39%
See More Skills

What skills can make your compensation higher?

Mastering certain specialized skills can lead to a significant increase in pay. Here are examples of skills and the potential impact they can have on a Claims Supervisor I's salary.

  • Public Speaking: Can increase your salary by up to 17%.
  • Claims Management: Can increase your salary by up to 13%.
  • Commitment: Can increase your salary by up to 13%.
Skill Salary Salary % Increase
Public Speaking $89,300
17%
Claims Management $86,247
13%
Commitment $86,247
13%
Get Latest Data

Claims Supervisor I Salary by Company Size: Startups vs. Enterprise

Claims Supervisor I salary potential scales significantly with company size. Data shows that Enterprise companies (5,000+ employees) pay the highest average salary at around $83,717. While startup companies pay approximate $70,910.

Claims Supervisor I Salary by Company Size

Company Size Employees Average Salary
Startup 1~50 $70,910
Growth Stage 51~500 $74,974
Established 501~5000 $80,864
Enterprise 5000+ $83,717

Claims Supervisor I Salary by Industry: Top Paying Sectors

For Claims Supervisor I roles, the industry you choose can affect earning potential by as much as 75% (the gap between the highest and lowest paying industries). Data shows that the Energy & Utilities and Financial Services sectors offer the strongest compensation, at 30% above the average. In contrast, Claims Supervisor positions in Retail & Wholesale or Transportation typically offer lower base pay, as these industries often view Claims Supervisor I as a support function rather than a direct revenue driver.

The top paying industries for a Claims Supervisor I

Industry Sector Average Annual Salary Average Hourly Rate Pay vs.Avg
Energy & Utilities$99,222$48.030%
Financial Services$91,590$44.020%
Insurance$87,774$42.015%
Business Services$83,958$40.010%

How Education impacts an Claims Supervisor I's Salary?

Your level of education can impact your salary potential. While many Claims Supervisor I enter the field with a Bachelor's Degree, higher education can lead to more specialized and higher-paying roles.

According to our 100% employer-reported salary data, the median salary for an Claims Supervisor I with a Bachelor's Degree is between $76,504 and $82,946.

Claims Supervisor I Salaries by Degree Level

Typical Education for Claims Supervisor I
Degree Level % of user with this level of education
No Diploma 2.9%
High School 13.5%
Associates 13.5%
Bachelors 54.8%
Masters 13.5%
Doctorate 1.9%
View as Graph

Claims Supervisor I Salary: Hourly Rate, Weekly Pay, and Monthly Pay

Understanding how a Claims Supervisor I's annual salary breaks down can help with budgeting. Below, you can see the average hourly rate, weekly pay, and monthly pay for this role. Use the buttons to switch between different pay periods.

Last Updated on August 01, 2026
$68,322
Average $76,325/year
$81,227
$5,694
Average $6,360/month
$6,769
$1,314
Average $1,468/week
$1,562
$33
Average $37/hour
$39
Annual Salary Monthly Pay Weekly Pay Hourly Wage
75th Percentile $81,227 $6,769 $1,562 $39
Average $76,325 $6,360 $1,468 $37
25th Percentile $68,322 $5,694 $1,314 $33

Claims Supervisor I Salary Growth & Career Path

Claims Supervisor I

Next Role

Advancement

Promotions are the fastest way to increase your earnings. As a Claims Supervisor I, you have the following paths for advancement. The table below compares the salary raises for common next-step roles. By comparing these figures, you can choose the career path that best meets your financial goals.

Next Step Role Estimate Salary Projected Raise
Claims Supervisor II $100,739 32%
Disability Claims Manager $101,541 33%

Most common benefits for Claims Supervisor I

  • Social Security
  • 401 (k)
  • Disability
  • Healthcare
  • Pension
  • Time Off (days)

Common company salaries for Claims Supervisor I

Here are companies hiring for Claims Supervisor I and their salaries, click below for more details.

Find Your Next Claims Supervisor I Job

Ready to take the next step in your career? Browse thousands of current Claims Supervisor I job openings on our job board. Use the search bar below to find your perfect match.

For Employees

Analyze the market and your qualifications to negotiate your salary with confidence.

Get a Salary Increase

Search thousands of open positions to find your next opportunity.

Search Job Openings

For Employers

Individualize employee pay based on unique job requirements and personal qualifications.

Adjust Employee Salary

Get the latest market price for benchmark jobs and jobs in your industry.

Price My Industry Jobs

FAQ about Claims Supervisor I

1. Where can a Claims Supervisor I earn the most?

A Claims Supervisor I's earning potential can vary widely depending on several factors, including location, industry, experience, education, and the specific employer. According to the latest salary data by Salary.com, a Claims Supervisor I earns the most in San Jose, CA, where the annual salary of a Claims Supervisor I is $96,269.

2. What is the highest pay for Claims Supervisor I?

The highest pay for Claims Supervisor I is $85,690.

3. What is the lowest pay for Claims Supervisor I?

The lowest pay for Claims Supervisor I is $61,036.

4. What are the responsibilities of Claims Supervisor I?

Supervises activities in the claims department to ensure efficient and accurate handling of assigned claims. Assigns and monitors caseloads to balance workload and meet established service and quality standards. Reviews claims decisions, reserves, and settlements to verify accuracy and adherence to authority limits. Provides coaching, training, and day-to-day technical guidance to support staff development and performance. Resolves escalated claims issues and complex inquiries from claimants, policyholders, and providers. Ensures compliance with company procedures, regulatory requirements, and documentation standards. Requires a bachelor's degree. Typically reports to a manager. Supervises a small group of para-professional staff in an organization characterized by highly transactional or repetitive processes. Contributes to the development of processes and procedures. Typically requires 3 years experience in the related area as an individual contributor. Thorough knowledge of functional area under supervision.

5. What industry pays the highest salary for Claims Supervisor I?

The Energy & Utilities industry offers the highest average compensation for Claims Supervisor I roles, with salaries approximately 30% above the market median.

Where Does Our Salary Data Come From?

Salary.com provides salary estimates, histograms, trends, and comparisons using data from employer job postings and third-party sources.

We offer detailed salary information across multiple percentiles for your reference. (Click here to learn Why the Salary Midpoint Formula Is Crucial for Achieving Pay Equity.)

With the most extensive online, real-time compensation data available, Salary.com helps you pinpoint your exact pay target.

Are you an HR manager or compensation specialist?

Salary.com's CompAnalyst platform offers:

  • Detailed skills and competency reports for specific positions
  • Job and employee pricing reports
  • Compensation data tools, salary structures, surveys and benchmarks.
Learn about CompAnalyst