Paul I Sheaffer Insurance Agency Salary

How Much Does Paul I Sheaffer Insurance Agency Pay?BETA

As of April 2025, the average annual salary for employees at Paul I Sheaffer Insurance Agency in the United States is $88,118. This translates to an approximate hourly wage of $42. Salaries at Paul I Sheaffer Insurance Agency typically range from $77,533 to $99,636 annually, reflecting the diverse roles and experience levels within the company. Individual salaries can vary significantly based on factors such as job role, experience, education level, certifications, and more. At Paul I Sheaffer Insurance Agency, A Controller is among the highest earners, with an average salary of approximately $204,167 per year. Conversely, the lowest-paid position is Commercial Insurance Processor, earning around $37,785 annually. Explore this page further for more salary and benefits information at Paul I Sheaffer Insurance Agency.

DISCLAIMER: The salary range presented here is an estimation that has been derived from our proprietary algorithm. It should be noted that this range does not originate from the company's factual payroll records or survey data.

How Much Does Paul I Sheaffer Insurance Agency Pay for Different Roles?BETA

At Paul I Sheaffer Insurance Agency, salaries can vary significantly based on factors such as location, industry, job category, and department. Below, we provide a detailed overview of salary ranges for various roles within the company.

It's important to note that salaries for the same position may differ due to several factors, including experience, education level, training, skills, and competencies. For instance, Controller positions at Paul I Sheaffer Insurance Agency offer the highest average annual salary of $204,167, while Commercial Insurance Processor roles have an average annual salary of $37,785.

JOB TITLE SALARY RANGE AVERAGE SALARY COMPANY NAME
Controller $173,896 - $234,267 $204,167 Paul I Sheaffer Insurance Agency
Principal $86,021 - $105,806 $96,158 Paul I Sheaffer Insurance Agency
Manager, Operations $81,644 - $102,131 $93,865 Paul I Sheaffer Insurance Agency
Claims Administrator $63,145 - $77,305 $69,986 Paul I Sheaffer Insurance Agency
Commercial Lines Account Manager $56,941 - $74,869 $65,227 Paul I Sheaffer Insurance Agency
Commercial Lines Processor $37,064 - $48,041 $41,878 Paul I Sheaffer Insurance Agency
Accounting $36,653 - $43,776 $40,102 Paul I Sheaffer Insurance Agency
Commercial Insurance Processor $36,761 - $38,516 $37,785 Paul I Sheaffer Insurance Agency
DISCLAIMER: The salary range presented here is an estimation that has been derived from our proprietary algorithm. It should be noted that this range does not originate from the company's factual payroll records or survey data.
How accurate dose the salary look to you?

Paul I Sheaffer Insurance Agency Overview

Website:
sheafferins.com
Size:
<25 Employees
Industry:
Insurance
Revenue:
$5M - $10M
About:
The Paul I. Sheaffer Insurance Agency was founded in 1951 to serve the insurance needs of individuals and families with professionalism, dedication and trust. The agency has grown into a full service agency representing over 40 insurance companies and insuring more that 2,400 families and 1,000 busi...

Most Common Benefits for Paul I Sheaffer Insurance Agency

Aside from the base salary, Paul I Sheaffer Insurance Agency offers its employees a list of benefits. Employee benefits are an important factor in considering a position posted by the company.
Social Security
401(K)
Disability
Healthcare
Pension
Time Off (days)
Work at Paul I Sheaffer Insurance Agency ?
Share your experience
How Much Should You Be Earning?

Get an estimated calculation of how much you should be earning and insight into your career options.

illustration

Job Openings at Paul I Sheaffer Insurance Agency

Planning your next career step? Take a look at the top jobs Paul I Sheaffer Insurance Agency is hiring for right now.

Similar Company Salary

Companies in the same industry have the same employee size, company type, similar revenue are similar companies. The table below shows the salary range and average salary of Paul I Sheaffer Insurance Agency ’s peer companies.
Ie Shaffer & Co Ewing, NJ $87,164 - $112,013 Company Salary Range $99,067 Average Company Salary
international specialty insurance sales Inc Scottsdale, AZ $80,108 - $103,002 Company Salary Range $91,071 Average Company Salary
Medley/Turrentine & Associates LLC Oklahoma City, OK $75,856 - $97,527 Company Salary Range $86,230 Average Company Salary
Advanced Insurance Solutions Inc Hershey, PA $77,853 - $100,051 Company Salary Range $88,487 Average Company Salary
Gettysburg Benefits Administrators Inc Gettysburg, PA $78,156 - $100,441 Company Salary Range $88,835 Average Company Salary
KAI Insurance Agencies Harrisburg, PA $78,605 - $101,014 Company Salary Range $89,342 Average Company Salary
DL Dravis & Associates Inc Altoona, PA $74,747 - $96,064 Company Salary Range $84,964 Average Company Salary
McGroarty & Bradburn Insurance Inc Pittsburgh, PA $80,126 - $102,978 Company Salary Range $91,071 Average Company Salary
PearsonRavitz Ardmore, PA $86,430 - $111,074 Company Salary Range $98,244 Average Company Salary
See more companies

FAQs About Paul I Sheaffer Insurance Agency Company

1. How much does Paul I Sheaffer Insurance Agency in the United States pay?

Paul I Sheaffer Insurance Agency pays its employees an average of $88,118 per year. The average salary at Paul I Sheaffer Insurance Agency range from $77,533 to $99,636 per year. Controller jobs at Paul I Sheaffer Insurance Agency earn the most with an average annual salary of $204,167, while Commercial Insurance Processor jobs earn the least with an average annual salary of $37,785.

2. Do Paul I Sheaffer Insurance Agency employees get a higher salary than other similar companies?

The salary at Paul I Sheaffer Insurance Agency is lesser than Ie Shaffer & Co. The highest salary package reported for an employee at Paul I Sheaffer Insurance Agency is $99,636 per year, meanwhile the highest salary package reported for an employee at Ie Shaffer & Co is $112,013 per year.

3. How much does Paul I Sheaffer Insurance Agency pay compared to Ie Shaffer & Co?

The average annual salary at Paul I Sheaffer Insurance Agency is $88,118, or an hourly wage of $42, in comparison to Ie Shaffer & Co which pays $99,067 per year or $48 per hour.

4. Which job skills can boost a Commercial Lines Account Manager salary at Paul I Sheaffer Insurance Agency?

Customer Service, Customer Success and Presentation are key to a Commercial Lines Account Manager job at Paul I Sheaffer Insurance Agency. Possessing these skills could lead to a higher salary. You can learn and develop high income skills now if you’re looking for a position at Paul I Sheaffer Insurance Agency.

5. What is the lowest salary at Paul I Sheaffer Insurance Agency?

The lowest paying job at Paul I Sheaffer Insurance Agency is Commercial Insurance Processor with an annual salary of $37,785 or an hourly rate of $42.