How Much Does a Property Claims Supervisor make?

Property Claims Supervisor made a median salary around $112,549 in December, 2024. The best-paid 25 percent made $123,819 probably that year, while the lowest-paid 25 percent made around $99,265. Salary ranges can vary widely depending on many important factors, including education, certifications, additional skills, the number of years you have spent in your profession. With more online, real-time compensation data than any other website, Salary.com helps you determine your exact pay target.
25% $99,265 10% $87,170 90% $134,080 75% $123,819 $112,549 50%(Median)
Check out Property Claims Supervisor jobs in Maine

RN Supervisor

Paul's Run - PHILADELPHIA, PA

RN Supervisor

Eden Rehabilitation and Healthcare - EDEN, NC

Nursing Supervisor

Preferred Transitions Home Health Agency - MILFORD, MA

General Liability Claims Specialist

CNA Insurance - DOWNERS GROVE, IL

download asset banner
Facing Salary Structure Challenges? Let Our Expert Guide You
The job market is increasingly challenging. Our whitepaper, Navigating the Challenges of Creating Salary Structures, offers guidance on creating salary structures. Provide your phone number and work email to download the full version.
We will handle your contact details in line with our Privacy Policy. If you prefer not to receive marketing emails from Salary.com, you can opt-out out of marketing communications at any time by clicking unsubscribe.

Best-Paying Cities for Property Claims Supervisor

The metropolitan areas that pay the highest salary in the Property Claims Supervisor profession are Eliot , Kittery , Kittery Point , York , York Beach .
Eliot, ME $120,300
Kittery, ME $120,300
Kittery Point, ME $120,300
York, ME $120,300
York Beach, ME $120,300

Best-Paying States for Property Claims Supervisor

The states and districts that pay Property Claims Supervisor the highest salary are District of Columbia (around $128,744) , California (around $127,587) , New Jersey (around $126,777) , Alaska (around $125,968) , and Massachusetts (around $125,852) .
District of Columbia $128,744
California $127,587
New Jersey $126,777
Alaska $125,968
Massachusetts $125,852

What is the Career Path of Property Claims Supervisor?

A career path is a sequence of jobs that leads to your short- and long-term career goals. Some follow a linear career path within one field, while others change fields periodically to achieve career or personal goals.

For Property Claims Supervisor, the first career path typically starts with a Health Underwriting Manager position , and then progresses to Health Underwriting Director.

The second career path typically starts with a Life Underwriting Manager position , and then progresses to Life Underwriting Director.

The third career path typically starts with a Property Casualty Underwriting Manager position , and then progresses to Property Casualty Underwriting Director.

Additionally, the fourth career path typically starts with an Underwriting Supervisor position , and then progresses to Chief Underwriting Officer.

Besides, Property Claims Supervisor can also turn to other related jobs, including Claims Supervisor II , Claims Supervisor I , Property/Casualty Claims Adjuster I and Property/Casualty Claims Adjuster II .

Frequently Asked Questions for Property Claims Supervisor

Q: What is the salary range of Property Claims Supervisor in Maine?
A: In 2024 , the lowest-paid Property Claims Supervisor in Maine earned an average annual salary of $99,265 , while the highest-paid made $123,819.
Q: What is the salary for a Property Claims Supervisor in California?
A: Property Claims Supervisor employed in California earned an average salary of $127,587 in 2024.

Average Property Claims Supervisor Pay vs. Other Jobs

Property Claims Supervisor earned an average salary of $112,549 in 2024. Other jobs related to Property Claims Supervisor earned the following average salary in December, 2024. Claims Supervisor II made $96,536 , Claims Supervisor I made $79,190 , Property/Casualty Claims Adjuster I and Property/Casualty Claims Adjuster II made $54,190 and $70,090 respectively .

Relevant Jobs of Property Claims Supervisor

Claims Supervisor II - Average Salary $96,536
Claims Supervisor II supervises most activities in the claims department. Leads the examination of personal and property and casualty insurance claims based on policy provisions, appraisal, and verifiable damage. Being a Claims Supervisor II interacts with claimants and oversees the review of records and documentation to ascertain insurance coverage. Supervises settlement negotiations within authorized limits and escalates claims exceeding authorization. Additionally, Claims Supervisor II may be responsible for reviewing and processing highly complex or high-value claims. May assist in training Property and Casualty Claims Examiners and Adjusters. May require a bachelor's degree. Typically reports to a manager or head of a unit/department. The Claims Supervisor II supervises a small group of para-professional staff in an organization characterized by highly transactional or repetitive processes. Contributes to the development of processes and procedures. To be a Claims Supervisor II typically requires 3 years experience in the related area as an individual contributor. Thorough knowledge of functional area under supervision.
Claims Supervisor I - Average Salary $79,190
Claims Supervisor I supervises activities in the claims department. Leads the examination of personal and property and casualty insurance claims based on policy provisions, appraisal, and verifiable damage. Being a Claims Supervisor I interacts with claimants and oversees the review of records and documentation to ascertain insurance coverage. Supervises settlement negotiations within authorized limits and escalates claims exceeding authorization. Additionally, Claims Supervisor I may conduct team training. May require a bachelor's degree. Typically reports to a manager or head of a unit/department. Working team member that may validate or coordinate the work of others on a support team. Suggests improvements to process, is a knowledge resource for other team members. Has no authority for staff actions. Generally has a minimum of 2 years experience as an individual contributor. Thorough knowledge of the team processes.
Property/Casualty Claims Adjuster I - Average Salary $54,190
The Property/Casualty Claims Adjuster I corresponds with policyholders, claimants, witnesses, attorneys, etc. to gather important information to support contested insurance claims. Denies, settles, or authorizes payments to routine property/casualty claims based on coverage, appraisal, and verifiable damage. Being a Property/Casualty Claims Adjuster I prepares reports of investigation findings. Makes recommendations for settlement of routine property/casualty claims based on coverage, appraisal, and verifiable damage. In addition, Property/Casualty Claims Adjuster I may conduct field evaluations to inspect and document damage or loss. Typically requires an associate's degree. Typically reports to a supervisor or manager. Being a Property/Casualty Claims Adjuster I works on projects/matters of limited complexity in a support role. Work is closely managed. Working as a Property/Casualty Claims Adjuster I typically requires 0-2 years of related experience.
Property/Casualty Claims Adjuster II - Average Salary $70,090
The Property/Casualty Claims Adjuster II is responsible for corresponding with policyholders, claimants, witnesses, attorneys, etc. to gather important information to support contested claims. Denies, settles, or authorizes payments to routine property/casualty claims based on coverage, appraisal, and verifiable damage. Being a Property/Casualty Claims Adjuster II may conduct field evaluations to inspect and document damage or loss. Prepares reports of investigation findings. In addition, Property/Casualty Claims Adjuster II typically requires an associate's degree. Typically reports to a supervisor or manager. Being a Property/Casualty Claims Adjuster II gains exposure to some of the complex tasks within the job function. Occasionally directed in several aspects of the work. Working as a Property/Casualty Claims Adjuster II typically requires 2 to 4 years of related experience.
Property Casualty Underwriting Supervisor - Average Salary $111,721
Property Casualty Underwriting Supervisor oversees activities of the property/casualty underwriting department. Provides supervision for a group of underwriters who review, analyze and inspect property/casualty insurance contracts, which includes accident insurance, crime insurance, loss of property insurance. Being a Property Casualty Underwriting Supervisor experienced in risk management and complex applications. Analyzes various rate plans utilizing a company's claims history to determine the appropriate rate plan and benefits costs. Additionally, Property Casualty Underwriting Supervisor may assist with analysis of large accounts. May require a bachelor's degree. Typically requires certification as a Chartered Property Casualty Underwriter (CPCU). Typically reports to a manager or head of a unit/department. The Property Casualty Underwriting Supervisor supervises a small group of para-professional staff in an organization characterized by highly transactional or repetitive processes. Contributes to the development of processes and procedures. To be a Property Casualty Underwriting Supervisor typically requires 3 years experience in the related area as an individual contributor. Thorough knowledge of functional area under supervision.