P & L Insurance Salary

P & L Insurance Salary

How Much Does P & L Insurance Pay for employees?

Salaries

Job Openings

Overview

Reviews

Similar Company

FAQ

Recommended HR Topics
Compensation Planning Hot Insights on Your Competitors' PayNew Global Market Data New Develop a Job Description Pay Equlity Benefits Consulting
As of August 2026, the average annual salary for employees at P & L Insurance in the United States is $81,439. This translates to an approximate hourly wage of $39. Salaries at P & L Insurance typically range from $73,502 to $90,999 annually, reflecting the diverse roles and experience levels within the company. P & L Insurance’s salaries are influenced by a wide range of factors including job role, department, years of experience, and location.
DISCLAIMER: The salary range presented here is an estimation that has been derived from our proprietary algorithm. It should be noted that this range does not originate from the company's factual payroll records or survey data.

How Much Does P & L Insurance Pay for Different Roles?

The table below outlines the annual salary ranges for popular roles within the company, helping you benchmark potential earnings. Use 'View by Card/Table' option to find the data most relevant to your career path.

Insurance Retention Specialist

$62,943 / year

Salary Range: $53,330 - $75,168

Sales

Allstate Insurance Customer Service Representative

$46,317 / year

Salary Range: $41,773 - $52,266

Customer Service

Management Trainee

$66,518 / year

Salary Range: $59,390 - $73,603

Automotive Repair

Insurance Sales Representative

$47,150 / year

Salary Range: $42,524 - $53,159

Medical Technology

Customer Service Representative

$40,328 / year

Salary Range: $36,517 - $45,032

Customer Service

Operations Manager

$117,248 / year

Salary Range: $104,811 - $130,828

Operations

DISCLAIMER: The salary range presented here is an estimation that has been derived from our proprietary algorithm. It should be noted that this range does not originate from the company's factual payroll records or survey data.

Turn Insight into Opportunity: Current Job Openings

Ready for your next career move? Explore current job openings at P & L Insurance.
Loading results...

About P & L Insurance: Company Profile

Website
www.americanadvantage.com
Founded In
1982
Employees
<25 employees
Industry
Insurance
Headquarter Location
MUSKEGO
Revenue
<$5 Million
Phone Number
-
Social Media

Employee Reviews: Insights on Salary, Culture & Work-Life

Gain authentic perspectives from current and former employees. These anonymous reviews offer invaluable insights into P & L Insurance's culture, work-life balance, management, and employee sentiment regarding salary satisfaction, bonus payouts, and benefits.
This company offers a fantastic work culture with a focus on employee growth. It’s a solid option for those in the insurance field. Work-life balance is a priority.
Commented in April 26, 2025
9
0
Managers are supportive of professional development. The company also hosts occasional social events, which boosts morale.
Commented in October 30, 2024
50
3
It’s a reliable workplace with standard industry benefits. I’m happy with my experience and the opportunities available. Overall, it’s a forward-thinking workplace. The workload is consistent, and overtime is rare. It’s a great place for career-minded insurance professionals. I’ve grown significantly in my role and appreciate the opportunities provided. Leadership is clear in expectations.
Commented in February 27, 2024
36
3

How P & L Insurance's Salaries Compare to Similar Companies?

The data below provides a snapshot of what comparable firms are paying, offering crucial context for evaluating P & L Insurance’s pay competitiveness. Click on a company for a deeper dive.

Is P & L Insurance’s Pay Competitive? Salary Benchmarking Analysis

How does P & L Insurance’s compensation stack up against the market? This analysis visualizes their average salary compared to its industry benchmark and key peer companies.
Peer Company & Industry Benchmarking
180k
150k
120k
90k
60k
30k
0
Average Salary ($/year)
P & L Insurance
Insurance
PACIFIC CLAIMS MANAGEMENT, LLC
PAYLESS AUTO INSURANCE
Industry Comparison
Our data shows that, on average, compensation at P & L Insurance is below the average for the U.S. Insurance industry by approximately 34%. This positioning suggests their pay is below the market average within their sector.
Peer Company Comparison
To provide a broader market perspective, we compared P & L Insurance average annual salary with several similar companies. P & L Insurance average salary of $81,439 is lower than PACIFIC CLAIMS MANAGEMENT, LLC, which has an average salary of $82,264. It is lower than PAYLESS AUTO INSURANCE, with their average salary at $89,162. This places P & L Insurance in a developing position among its peers.
See Your True Competitors
The companies behind the question marks could be hiring your best people. Don't operate with incomplete data. Unlock your full competitive view with Salary.com for Business to precisely benchmark salaries, benefits, and more against your true competitors.

What Is the Cost of Living Near Milwaukee?

Understanding the cost of living near Milwaukee is key to truly evaluating a salary offer or your current compensation at P & L Insurance.
Milwaukee's Cost of Living Index is approximately 85.9 (14.1% less expensive than US average; 9.4% less than WI average). Largest WI city, Lake Michigan, affordable housing. MCTS bus, The Hop streetcar (free). When planning your budget based on a salary from P & L Insurance, consider these typical monthly expenses:
Expense Category Estimated Monthly Cost Key Considerations / Notes
Housing (1-BR Apt Rent) $950 - $1,400+ A significant portion of P & L Insurance salary. Location choices impact this heavily.
Utilities (Basic) $130 - $220 Electricity, Heating, Cooling, Water etc.
Public Transportation $72 (MCTS monthly pass) Essential for most commuters; car ownership is costly.
Groceries (Single Person) $390 - $570 Can be higher with more dining out or specialty stores.
Personal & Leisure $380 - $700+ Dining out, entertainment, shopping. Highly variable.
Healthcare (Individual) $370 - $690+ Varies significantly by plan & employer contribution.
Subtotal (Excluding Taxes) $2,292 - $3,582+ This subtotal does not include income taxes (federal, state, local), which can significantly impact your take-home pay.

Most Common Questions About P & L Insurance

FAQ 1: What is the typical salary range (low to high) for most roles at P & L Insurance?
The typical annual salary range for most roles at P & L Insurance is approximately from $73,502 to $90,999. It's important to remember that these are overall averages, actual salaries vary significantly based on specific job titles, years of experience, skills, and location.
FAQ 2: How much does P & L Insurance pay compared to PACIFIC CLAIMS MANAGEMENT, LLC?
The average annual salary at P & L Insurance is $81,439, or an hourly wage of $39, in comparison to PACIFIC CLAIMS MANAGEMENT, LLC which pays $82,264 per year or $40 per hour.
FAQ 3: How does experience level affect salary at P & L Insurance?
Experience level is a significant factor in determining salary at P & L Insurance, as it is with most employers. Generally, employees with more years of relevant experience and a proven track record can command higher salaries. For example, a senior-level role will typically have a higher pay band than an entry-level or mid-career position within the same job family.
FAQ 4: How can I determine if a salary offer from P & L Insurance in Milwaukee is fair given the local cost of living?
To determine if a salary offer from P & L Insurance in Milwaukee is fair, first compare the gross salary to our data for similar roles at P & L Insurance and its competitors (see our similar company salaries section) . Then, critically, use our "Cost of Living Insights for Milwaukee" to understand its purchasing power.
FAQ 5: Are the salaries listed for P & L Insurance on Salary.com pre-tax or after-tax?
All salary figures displayed for P & L Insurance, including average base salary and estimated total compensation, are pre-tax amounts. They do not account for federal, state, or local income taxes, nor deductions for benefits like health insurance or 401(k) contributions.

For Employer

What Should I Pay?

The trusted data and intuitive software your organization needs to get pay right.

Explore CompAnalyst ®
Looking for Accurate Salary Data?

Enhance your organization's compensation strategy with salary data sets that HR and team managers can use to pay your staff right.

Surveys & Data Sets
Unlock Intelligence on Your Competitors' Salaries Across 35 Countries

Real-time global intelligence that empowers you to make competitive pay decisions and align offers with global trends.

SalaryIQTM
The Only Compensation System That Helps You EXCEL.

If your compensation planning software is too rigid to deploy winning incentive strategies, it’s time to find an adaptable solution.

Compensation Planning