How Much Does a Benefit Counselor Make in New York, NY?

Updated April 01, 2025
As of April 01, 2025, the average annual pay of Benefit Counselor in New York, NY is $70,583. While Salary.com is seeing that Benefit Counselor salary in New York, NY can go up to $86,596 or down to $53,562, but most earn between $61,674 and $78,965. Salary ranges can vary widely depending on many important factors, including education, certifications, additional skills, and your experience levels. With more online, real-time compensation data than any other website, Salary.com helps you determine your exact pay target.
Related Job Titles to Benefit Counselor
Benefit Analyst
$87,641
New York, NY
Per Year
Benefit Administrator
$83,104
New York, NY
Per Year
Benefit Coordinator
$83,104
New York, NY
Per Year
Benefit Manager
$143,693
New York, NY
Per Year
download asset banner
Facing Salary Structure Challenges? Let Our Expert Guide You
The job market is increasingly challenging. Our whitepaper, Navigating the Challenges of Creating Salary Structures, offers guidance on creating salary structures. Provide your phone number and work email to download the full version.
We will handle your contact details in line with our Privacy Policy. If you prefer not to receive marketing emails from Salary.com, you can opt-out out of marketing communications at any time by clicking unsubscribe.

Similar Job Salaries to Benefit Counselor by Company

FIND A SPECIFIC EMPLOYER
Loading results...
Company average base salary in (usd) range
PrestigePEO
Benefit Specialist
$74,599/yr
$66,627
$82,570
RANGE: $66,627 - $82,570
UR Thompson Health
Benefit Manager
$101,386/yr
$91,056
$111,715
RANGE: $91,056 - $111,715
Paychex
Benefit Administration Analyst
$67,864/yr
$60,565
$75,163
RANGE: $60,565 - $75,163
Group Management Services, Inc.
Benefit Sales Representitive
$77,508/yr
$68,847
$86,169
RANGE: $68,847 - $86,169
Agent Alliance Inc.
Virtual Supplemental Benefit Representative
$75,768/yr
$67,159
$84,377
RANGE: $67,159 - $84,377
VirtualVocations
Public Benefit Specialist
$51,740/yr
$46,951
$56,530
RANGE: $46,951 - $56,530
AssuredPartners
Employee Benefit Account Executive
$100,269/yr
$88,127
$112,411
RANGE: $88,127 - $112,411
Fidelis Care
Health Benefit Rep - Seneca
$64,358/yr
$58,098
$70,618
RANGE: $58,098 - $70,618
Lensa
Senior Benefit Review Specialist
$117,931/yr
$105,343
$130,518
RANGE: $105,343 - $130,518
KPH Healthcare Services
Senior Benefit Operations Specialist
$70,060/yr
$62,756
$77,365
RANGE: $62,756 - $77,365

Open Benefit Counselor Jobs in New York, NY

Create Alert

What Does a Benefit Counselor Do?

ALEX is an interactive decision-support tool and an informative, virtual benefits counselor that helps you learn about the UW System’s comprehensive benefits in a personalized way.
Updated December 01, 2021
On your own, but a Benefits Counselor can offer you expert guidance based on your specific circumstances.
Updated November 28, 2021
Having to pay out-of-pocket for education, which benefits not only counselors themselves but also the institutions they work for and the clients they serve, can be a major disincentive for counselors.
Updated November 26, 2021
If you are thinking of becoming a Benefits Counselor or planning the next step in your career, find details about.
Updated November 17, 2021
Depending on the work environment, benefits counselors may also need to be familiar with other incentives like 401(k), pensions, and stock ownership.
Updated November 06, 2021

Frequently Asked Questions About a Benefit Counselor Salaries

What is the average of a Benefit Counselor in New York, NY?

The Benefit Counselor salary range is from $61,674 to $78,965, and the average Benefit Counselor salary is $70,583/year in New York, NY. The Benefit Counselor's salary will change in different locations.

Which location pays the highest Benefit Counselor salary in the United States?

The Benefit Counselor salary in San Jose, CA is $76,820 which is the highest in the US.

What kinds of reasons will influence the Benefit Counselor's salary?

Besides the location, employees' education degree, related skills, and work experience also will influence the salary. Try to improve your skills and experience to get a higher salary for the position of Benefit Counselor.

What is the growth rate of the Benefit Counselor's salary?

If you are thinking of becoming a Benefit Counselor or planning the next step in your career, find the detailed salary report of a Benefit Counselor.