Willoughby Insurance Salary

As of August 2026, the average annual salary for employees at Willoughby Insurance in the United States is $86,958. This translates to an approximate hourly wage of $42. Salaries at Willoughby Insurance typically range from $76,515 to $98,332 annually, reflecting the diverse roles and experience levels within the company.

How Much Does Willoughby Insurance Pay for Different Roles?

Explore detailed salary information for specific jobs at Willoughby Insurance. Based on our data, the highest paying job is the Manager, with an annual salary of $89,229. The table below outlines the annual salary ranges for most popular roles within the company.
How accurate does the salary look to you?

Current Job Openings at Willoughby Insurance

Ready for your next career move? Explore current job openings at Willoughby Insurance. Use the search tool below to find available positions by title and location and apply directly to start your career.

Is Willoughby Insurance’s Pay Competitive? Salary Benchmarking Analysis

How does Willoughby Insurance's compensation stack up against the industry and its key competitors? Our salary benchmarking analysis provides a clear comparison. The chart below visualizes this comparison alongside select peer companies.
Competitor / Benchmark Avg. Salary Variance Primary Market Influence Factor & Explanation
PointGuard Advisors $90,112
+3.6%
Data suggests PointGuard Advisors's workforce skews heavily towards veteran, high-tenure roles.
ABA Insurance Agency $104,457
+20.1%
Reflects structural premiums typical of ABA Insurance Agency's large-cap national operations.
InsureWorkforce LLC $82,717
-4.9%
Normalized for lower cost-of-living zones where InsureWorkforce LLC primarily operates.
David E Zeller Insurance Agency Inc $100,681
+15.8%
Reflects a supply-demand imbalance for the specific talent David E Zeller Insurance Agency Inc targets.
Insurance Industry $123,858
+42.4%
Pay variances are driven by organizational scale, specialized skill requirements, or geographic cost-of-living factors.
Need More Granular Data? The analysis above provides a high-level market overview. To benchmark specific job codes, adjust for real-time cost-of-living changes, or access verified HR-reported datasets, upgrade to Salary.com for Business. Precision matters when building your compensation strategy.

Employee Reviews: Working at Willoughby Insurance

Considering a career at Willoughby Insurance? Explore authentic employee reviews to learn about the work environment, career growth opportunities, pay transparency and benefits. These first-hand insights can help you set realistic compensation expectations and make informed career decisions.
Managers are approachable and supportive, making it easy to voice ideas. Work-life balance is respected, and flexible hours are a major perk. A fantastic place to grow in the insurance industry. The company’s culture is collaborative, and employee feedback is taken seriously. I’ve thoroughly enjoyed my time here. This company offers a supportive and engaging work environment. This company operates...
Work-life balance is respected, making this a great long-term career option. The leadership team is approachable and genuinely listens to feedback. The office is well-designed, promoting productivity. I’ve been impressed by the company’s commitment to innovation in insurance solutions.
I enjoy working here—the team is knowledgeable and always willing to help. Compensation is competitive, and work-life balance is prioritized. Regular training sessions keep us updated on industry trends. There’s a clear path for advancement, and managers actively help you reach your goals. Compensation is fair, and there’s recognition for hard work.

Willoughby Insurance Overview

Website
www.willoughbyinsurance.com
Founded In
1981
Employees
<25 employees
Industry
Insurance
Headquarter Address
8350 Main St Williamsville New York NY 14221
Revenue
<$5 Million
Phone Number
+1 7168858100
Social Media
About Willoughby Insurance
Willoughby Insurance is your dedicated insurance agency, serving the community of Buffalo and all of Western New York for over 60 Years! As Certified Insurance Counselors, the Willoughbys have the knowledge and expertise to provide an insurance solution to each and every client that offers value, security, and peace of mind. At Willoughby Insurance, we build trusting partnerships with our customer

What Benefits Does Willoughby Insurance Offer Beyond Salary?

A competitive compensation package is more than just a salary. Willoughby Insurance offers a comprehensive benefits package designed to support your health, financial future, and overall well-being. Below are the most common key benefits:
Social Security
401(K)
Disability
Healthcare
Pension
Time Off (days)
Work at Willoughby Insurance?
Share your experience
How Much Should You Be Earning?

Get an estimated calculation of how much you should be earning and insight into your career options.

illustration

What Is the Cost of Living Near Buffalo?

Understanding the cost of living near Buffalo is key to truly evaluating a salary offer or your current compensation at Willoughby Insurance.
Buffalo's Cost of Living Index is approximately 79.5 (20.5% less expensive than US average; 36.4% less than NY average). Western NY city, very affordable housing, revitalizing. NFTA Metro Bus/Rail. When planning your budget based on a salary from Willoughby Insurance, consider these typical monthly expenses:
Expense Category Estimated Monthly Cost Key Considerations / Notes
Housing (1-BR Apt Rent) $900 - $1,400+ A significant portion of Willoughby Insurance salary. Location choices impact this heavily.
Utilities (Basic) $160 - $270 (Heating significant) Electricity, Heating, Cooling, Water etc.
Public Transportation $75 (NFTA monthly pass) Essential for most commuters; car ownership is costly.
Groceries (Single Person) $380 - $560 Can be higher with more dining out or specialty stores.
Personal & Leisure $330 - $630+ Dining out, entertainment, shopping. Highly variable.
Healthcare (Individual) $370 - $690+ Varies significantly by plan & employer contribution.
Subtotal (Excluding Taxes) $2,215 - $3,555+ This subtotal does not include income taxes (federal, state, local), which can significantly impact your take-home pay.

FAQs of Willoughby Insurance

1. How much does a Willoughby Insurance employee make?

Willoughby Insurance pays its employees an average of $86,958 per year. The average salary at Willoughby Insurance range from $76,515 to $98,332 per year. It's important to remember that these are overall averages, actual salaries vary significantly based on specific job titles, years of experience, skills, and location.

2. Which similar company tend to pay more or less than Willoughby Insurance?

The salary at Willoughby Insurance is lesser than the similar company. The average annual salary at Willoughby Insurance is $86,958, or an hourly wage of $42, in comparison to PointGuard Advisors which pays $90,112 per year or $43 per hour.

3. How much does a Manager typically earn at Willoughby Insurance?

A Manager at Willoughby Insurance typically earns an average annual base salary of around $89,229, with a general range of $79,472 to $98,836.

4. Do employees with advanced degrees (Master's, PhD) earn more at Willoughby Insurance?

In many roles at Willoughby Insurance, particularly those requiring specialized knowledge or research capabilities (e.g., certain engineering, scientific, or financial roles), an advanced degree like a Master's or PhD can lead to a higher starting salary and faster career progression, thus higher earnings. However, for some roles, direct experience and skills might be valued as much or more than an advanced degree. The impact varies by field and specific job requirements.

5. How does the cost of living near Buffalo affect the perceived value of a Willoughby Insurance salary?

Buffalo's Cost of Living Index is approximately 79.5 (20.5% less expensive than US average; 36.4% less than NY average). This significantly impacts the purchasing power of a salary from Willoughby Insurance based there. Our "Cost of Living Insights for Buffalo" module details this impact, helping you assess the 'real feel' value of your compensation.

6. What kind of benefits does Willoughby Insurance typically offer employees?

Willoughby Insurance generally offers a range of employee benefits designed to support their workforce's health, financial well-being, and work-life balance. Comprehensive health insurance (medical, dental, vision), a 401(k) retirement savings plan (often with a company match), paid time off (PTO), and potentially disability and life insurance are included. For a more detailed list of benefits, please see our "Employee Benefits at Willoughby Insurance" section on this page.