As of May 01, 2025, the average annual salary for a Payroll Administrator I in Colorado is $62,904. Salary.com reports that pay typically ranges from $57,065 to $68,541, with most professionals earning between $51,750 and $73,673.
| Annual Salary |
Monthly Pay |
Weekly Pay |
Hourly Wage |
|
| 75th Percentile | $68,541 | $5,712 | $1,318 | $33 |
| Average | $62,904 | $5,242 | $1,210 | $30 |
| 25th Percentile | $57,065 | $4,755 | $1,097 | $27 |
An entry-level Payroll Administrator I with under 1 year experience makes about $62,468. With less than 2 years of experience, a mid-level Payroll Administrator I makes around $63,072. After 2-4 years, the Payroll Administrator I pay rises to about $64,334. Those senior Payroll Administrator I with 5-8 years of experience earn roughly $64,586, and those Payroll Administrator I having 8 years or more experience are expected to earn about $64,755 on average.
| Levels | Salary |
|---|---|
| Entry Level Payroll Administrator I | $62,468 |
| Intermediate Level Payroll Administrator I | $63,072 |
| Senior Level Payroll Administrator I | $64,334 |
| Specialist Level Payroll Administrator I | $64,586 |
| Expert Level Payroll Administrator I | $64,755 |
| Entry Level | 1% |
| Mid Level | 2% |
| Senior Level | 4% |
| Top Level | 5% |
| Experienced | 5% |
Not the salary data you are looking for? Choose the state salary you want to see.
What Am I Worth?
Not the salary data you are looking for? Choose the city salary you want to see.
Salary.com job board provides millions of Payroll Administrator I information for you to search for. Click on search button below to see Payroll Administrator I job openings or enter a new job title here.
Payroll Administrator I salary varies from city to city. Compared with national average salary of Payroll Administrator I, the highest Payroll Administrator I salary is in San Francisco, CA, where the Payroll Administrator I salary is 24.9% above. The lowest Payroll Administrator I salary is in Miami, FL, where the Payroll Administrator I salary is 3.9% lower than national average salary.
| City, State | Price | Compared to national average |
|---|---|---|
| San Francisco, CA | $76,997 |
24.9%
|
| Washington, DC | $68,261 |
10.7%
|
| Miami, FL | $59,235 |
|
| Chicago, IL | $63,711 |
3.3%
|
| Boston, MA | $68,760 |
11.5%
|
| New York, NY | $71,449 |
15.9%
|
