As of April 01, 2025, the average annual salary for a Claims Supervisor I in West Orange, NJ is $84,341. Salary.com reports that pay typically ranges from $80,096 to $95,599, with most professionals earning between $76,231 and $105,850.
| Annual Salary |
Monthly Pay |
Weekly Pay |
Hourly Wage |
|
| 75th Percentile | $84,422 | $7,035 | $1,624 | $41 |
| Average | $74,480 | $6,207 | $1,432 | $36 |
| 25th Percentile | $70,731 | $5,894 | $1,360 | $34 |
An entry-level Claims Supervisor I with under 1 year experience makes about $82,757. With less than 2 years of experience, a mid-level Claims Supervisor I makes around $82,947. After 2-4 years, the Claims Supervisor I pay rises to about $83,581. Those senior Claims Supervisor I with 5-8 years of experience earn roughly $84,341, and those Claims Supervisor I having 8 years or more experience are expected to earn about $87,198 on average.
| Levels | Salary |
|---|---|
| Entry Level Claims Supervisor I | $82,757 |
| Intermediate Level Claims Supervisor I | $82,947 |
| Senior Level Claims Supervisor I | $83,581 |
| Specialist Level Claims Supervisor I | $84,341 |
| Expert Level Claims Supervisor I | $87,198 |
| Entry Level | 11% |
| Mid Level | 11% |
| Senior Level | 12% |
| Top Level | 13% |
| Experienced | 17% |
Not the salary data you are looking for? Choose the city salary you want to see.
Salary.com job board provides millions of Claims Supervisor I information for you to search for. Click on search button below to see Claims Supervisor I job openings or enter a new job title here.
Each competency has five to ten behavioral assertions that can be observed, each with a corresponding performance level (from one to five) that is required for a particular job.
Leadership: Knowledge of and ability to employ effective strategies that motivate and guide other members within our business to achieve optimum results.
Microsoft Office: Microsoft Office is a suite of desktop productivity applications that is designed by Microsoft for business use. You can create documents containing text and images, work with data in spreadsheets and databases, create presentations and posters.
Group Insurance: A type of insurance plan that covers a number of people in the same contract. Such a plan provides the same level of insurance coverage to all members of a group irrespective of their age, gender, occupation or socio-economic status.
| Skill | Salary | Demand |
|---|---|---|
|
Public Speaking
|
$98,679 |
17%
|
|
Claims Management
|
$95,306 |
13%
|
|
Commitment
|
$95,306 |
13%
|
|
Teamwork
|
$94,462 |
12%
|
|
Claim Reviews
|
$93,619 |
11%
|
|
Initiative
|
$93,619 |
11%
|
