Salary Reviews: What to Expect and How to Succeed

Written by Salary.com Staff
February 6, 2024
Salary Reviews: What to Expect and How to Succeed

When it is time for the annual salary review, it can feel a little like a trip to the principal's office. Employees hope for the best but fear the worst. The good news is, with some preparation and perspective, they can ace that review and get the compensation they deserve.

This article will walk through what to expect during salary reviews, how to put the best foot forward, and tips for getting the salary bump you want. Whether you are a pro at reviews or gearing up for your first one, you will learn insider secrets to help make your next salary review a success.

Are you Paying Fairly and Equally?

What is a Salary Review?

A salary review is a periodic evaluation of an employee's compensation. It involves reviewing job performance and deciding correct pay adjustments. Companies conduct salary reviews annually or bi-annually. The goal is to ensure pay is fair and competitive. This process helps keep top talent.

During reviews, managers consider factors such as experience, input, and market rates for the role. Employees receive feedback on strengths, growth areas, and justification for any pay changes. Positive involvement can lead to a pay increase. Underperformers may see no change or a reduced salary.

Understanding the process helps employees prepare and make the most of these crucial career discussions.

Why Do Companies Pay People?

Companies need talented people to operate and grow the business. Paying competitive wages allows them to attract and keep skilled employees. Compensation provides an incentive for employees to perform their jobs well and be productive. Higher pay motivates employees to work harder.

Fair pay ensures employees feel valued and pushes loyalty. When employees feel valued, they are more engaged with a lesser chance of leaving.

Labor is a major operating cost for companies. Managing compensation well helps control losses and maximize profits. Payroll enables companies to comply with minimum salary laws and offer benefits that support recruitment and retention goals.

Competitive and fair pay allows companies to build strong, talented teams to achieve business goals. Strategic compensation management is a key for controlling costs while investing in human capital.

The Challenge for Companies to Stay Within Budget

Companies aim to provide fair raises while controlling costs. This requires balancing employee expectations with business needs. Budgets set compensation limits. Managers must decide raises based on performance, not exceed set amounts.

Employees want maximum increases, but companies cannot always accommodate requests. The review process aims to align pay with contribution. Top performers may get higher raises; underperformers may get none.

Communication and transparency help manage expectations. Employees must understand how raises are determined. With proper preparation and perspective, reviews can meet both company and employee goals. The focus must stay on performance, not just compensation.

The Approval Process of Salary Reviews

The process of approving salary reviews involves several key steps:

  • HR gathers data on company budgets, job performance, and market rates to make proposals.
  • Managers review proposals and provide additional context on employee contributions.
  • Senior leadership analyses the full picture and signs off on final salary adjustments.
  • Employees are notified of new compensation packages.

The goal is to make objective, fair decisions aligned with business needs and merits. Open communication ensures all parties understand the basis.

Key System Capabilities for Salary Reviews

Performance data collection and analysis tools are used to gather metrics on employees. This provides the raw info for salary decisions.

  • Compensation benchmarking to see current market rates for roles. This process is key to ensuring companies set fair pay.
  • Customizable compensation models to define pay grades, bands, and structures. Doing this aligns pay with strategy.
  • Automated approval workflows for salary change requests. Companies use this to simplify the review and approval process.
  • Reporting and analytics to track outcomes and see the full picture. This is a vital step that supports data-driven decisions.
  • Integration with core HR systems such as payroll, benefits, etc. Effective system integration connects compensation tools with other programs.
  • Self-service portal for employees. Offering this option allows employees to have access to view vital compensation data.
  • Configurable security settings. The entire process of compensation management entails robust security measures. Leveraging this controls access to sensitive salary data.

The right capabilities will optimize the entire salary review process from start to finish.

What to Expect During the Salary Review Process

The salary review process typically involves:

  • A self-evaluation where the employee reflects on achievements, skills gained, and areas for growth. This helps provide context for the manager's evaluation.
  • The manager completes a performance review, assesses employee's contributions and growth over the review period.
  • A salary proposal from the manager based on performance, experience, and market rates. This goes to HR.
  • HR benchmarking the proposed salary against industry standards and internal equity.
  • A salary review meeting between manager and employee to discuss the evaluation. This is a chance for the employees to advocate for oneself.
  • Notification from HR of any salary change. Adjustments usually take effect at the start of the fiscal year.

The employee's attitude, preparation, and engagement in the process can positively influence the outcome.

How to Have a Successful Salary Review Discussion

When meeting with your manager for a salary review, preparation is the key. Make sure to:

  • Highlight your major successes and quantify your impact on the company. Always use data and facts.
  • Research typical salaries for your role and experience level within your location.
  • Have a specific salary bump in mind but be flexible. Consider benefits and perks too.
  • Make you justify your case politely and professionally. Avoid resorting to using ultimatums.
  • Be receptive to feedback on areas for growth.
  • Say thank you after the review session. Maintain a cheerful outlook no matter the outcome.

With the right mindset and preparation, employees can have a productive discussion and negotiate effectively. They must be open-minded, focused on shared goals, and show their value.

Conclusion

Salary reviews can feel intimidating and full of uncertainty. But employees must be prepared with the right attitude, data, and approach to make sure they get what they deserve. They do not need to be afraid to engage in the process and advocate for themselves.

With the right expectations and preparation, employees can be ready to have a productive conversation about their value and take the next step in their careers. At the end of the day, salary reviews are an opportunity, not an obstacle. Employees must maintain perspective, focus on growth, and they will find themselves on the path to success.

Insights You Need to Get It Right

The latest research, expert advice, and compensation best practices all in one place.
Creating a Compensation Plan
Creating a Compensation Plan Blog
How the compensation and total rewards planning process create a compensation plan.

Read More

Top Compensation Trends in 2023
Top Compensation Trends in 2023 Blog
Stay ahead of the curve with these top compensation trends for 2023.

Read More

DE&I Panel Discussion: Moving the Conversation Forward
DE&I Panel Discussion: Moving the Conversation Forward Webinar
In this panel discussion we will cover what the issue is when improving DE&I.

Read More

Differences Between HR-Reported and Crowd-Sourced Compensation Data
Differences Between HR-Reported and Crowd-Sourced Compensation Data White paper
To make decisions about the value of a job, you need data from a range of sources.

Read More

CompAnalyst Market Data: Smart Matches, Fast Prices, and New Insights
CompAnalyst Market Data: Smart Matches, Fast Prices, and New Insights Product Sheet
The CompAnalyst Market Data platform is easier to use than ever before.

Read More

It's Easy to Get Started

Transform compensation at your organization and get pay right — see how with a personalized demo.